The Lift Line
“Glory lies not in never falling but rising every time you fall.” (Oliver Goldsmith, quoted by the author)
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
This column in The Indian Express of 7 October 2026 is by Ashok Lavasa, a former Election Commissioner of India, which gives it unusual weight: he writes as one who has sat at the Commission’s table. He argues that the Election Commission of India (ECI) has tied itself in “knots of its own making” over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, and that only transparency can untie them.
The story has run through our pages: the two Election Commissioners’ objections in a 24 September editorial, the legal basis of the SIR as argued by P.D.T. Achary in a 5 October editorial, and the forms used in the revision in the 4 October roundup. This column adds an insider’s view of collective functioning and the Form 6 dispute.
GS Paper 2: Appointment to various constitutional posts, powers, functions and responsibilities of constitutional bodies; salient features of the Representation of the People Act. GS Paper 4: Accountability, transparency and probity in public institutions.
Background and Context
The Commission and its law
| Provision | What it says |
|---|---|
| Article 324(1) | Superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and elections vest in the ECI |
| Article 324(2)-(3) | The ECI consists of the CEC and such other ECs as the President fixes; the CEC acts as Chairman |
| Article 324(5) | The CEC is removable only like a Supreme Court judge; other ECs only on the CEC’s recommendation |
| RP Act, 1950, Section 21 | Preparation and revision of electoral rolls; the SIR is conducted under it |
| Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 | Form 6 (new enrolment), Form 7 (objection or deletion), Form 8 (correction or shifting) |
| CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023 | Appointment by a committee of the PM, a Union Minister and the Leader of Opposition; decisions by majority |
| T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995) | The CEC and ECs share power; the Commission decides as a body, by majority if members differ |
Background: the dispute, in sequence
| Date | Development |
|---|---|
| 27 May 2026 | Supreme Court upholds the SIR with safeguards; para 152 recognises a bounded “residual authority” over documentation |
| 14 August 2026 | Background to the present row: an Election Commissioner’s letter calls the Form 6 changes “illegal and unauthorised” (as cited by the author) |
| September 2026 | The Indian Express reports 14 letters of objection by ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi while Gyanesh Kumar is CEC |
| 23 September | ECI says all decisions were unanimous |
| 26 September | ECI admits using two versions of Form 6, for SIR and non-SIR purposes; says the Supreme Court upheld the changes; later withdraws the declaration attached to Form 6 |
| 5 October | At a hearing, the CJI reportedly says: “No modified Form 6 has been approved by us” |
The Analysis
1. Friendless, and by its own effort. Lavasa opens with a lament. An organisation that “endeared itself by its friendly approach” now finds itself friendless. Its only friend, the ruling party, “pushes it further into a corner each time it comes to its defence”. Criticism comes from almost every quarter: people, civil society, retired civil servants, former judges, practising lawyers, political parties, newspapers’ editorials and YouTubers.
2. The courts are closing in. High courts have questioned some ECI decisions; serving judges have spoken against mass disenfranchisement; former ECs and CECs have questioned its conduct; and petitions seeking the suspension of the CEC have been admitted by the Supreme Court, the author writes. Then, on 5 October, the CJI reportedly observed that no modified Form 6 had been approved by the Court.
3. Three answers, each worse than the last. The ECI’s responses to the Indian Express report, Lavasa says, “added to its miseries”:
| Response | What the ECI said | The author’s reading |
|---|---|---|
| 23 September | All decisions unanimous | “I plead not-guilty” |
| 26 September | Two versions of Form 6 used; the Supreme Court “upheld” the changes | A climbdown that created confusion |
| Then | Declaration attached to Form 6 withdrawn | “As if it was hiding the weapon used in the crime” |
4. What para 152 really says. The legal background is para 152 of the Supreme Court’s 27 May judgment, which the ECI’s supporters cite. It says Form 6 is tailored to revision under Section 21(2) of the RP Act and may not always fit an intensive revision; the Commission therefore “retains a degree of residual authority to formulate an appropriate documentation framework”, but “such authority, however, is not unbounded”, must remain “cognisant of the existing statutory scheme”, and any departure needs “a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved”. Lavasa calls this “legalese at its ambivalent best”. Does it recognise only an authority to formulate, not approval of a specific form? And if the ECI relied on it, why did an EC, nearly three months later, call the changes illegal, and did the Commission ever examine his objections?
5. The dissent is about process, not the SIR itself. The letters, Lavasa notes, do not necessarily oppose the SIR. They reportedly objected to:
- the “illegalities” in changing Form 6;
- denying Electoral Registration Officers access to ECINet, which impeded their statutory duties;
- being excluded from decisions: no meetings for four months, no agenda or minutes circulated for a year;
- 16 lakh appeals filed before appellate tribunals against inclusion in West Bengal’s “purified” roll without their knowledge.
“These made the ECI’s functioning questionable.”
6. The remedy: publish the minutes. The SIR, “arguably an abrupt, aggressive and ambitious decision”, was widely perceived as “unfair, exclusionary and arbitrary”. If the ECI wants people to believe the decision was unanimous, Lavasa says, it must put the minutes of the relevant meeting in the public domain.
7. Can anyone be held to account? The Supreme Court may set aside decisions it finds illegal. But whether that would cost the CEC or ECs their posts is another matter: impeachment is politically fraught, and “the call of the conscience is a far cry”. Lavasa compares the institution to Milton’s fallen angels, and ends with Goldsmith’s line from The Citizen of the World (1762): institutions too can rise after a fall. “Let Nirvachan Sadan take the lead.”
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
Constitution and cases:
- Article 324: ECI; 324(5): CEC removed like a Supreme Court judge; ECs only on the CEC’s recommendation.
- Article 326: elections on the basis of adult suffrage (18 years).
- T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995): multi-member Commission upheld; decisions by majority.
- ECI constituted on 25 January 1950 (observed as National Voters’ Day); multi-member since 1 October 1993.
Statute and forms:
- RP Act, 1950, Section 21: preparation and revision of rolls; the SIR is conducted under it.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: Form 6 enrolment, Form 7 objection or deletion, Form 8 correction or shifting.
- CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023: selection committee of the PM, a Union Cabinet Minister and the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha; term six years or age 65.
Office-holders (October 2026):
- CEC: Gyanesh Kumar; ECs: Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.
- Nirvachan Sadan: the ECI’s headquarters in New Delhi.
⚠️ Watch the trap: The SIR is conducted under Section 21 of the RP Act, 1950, which deals with electoral rolls, not under the RP Act, 1951, which deals with the conduct of elections. And only the CEC enjoys judge-like protection from removal; an EC can be removed on the CEC’s recommendation.
The Debate
For the author’s view. A multi-member Commission exists precisely so that no single officer controls elections. If members are not consulted, meetings are not held and minutes are not circulated, the design is hollowed out. Shifting explanations and a reported remark from the CJI that contradicts the ECI’s own claim deepen the trust deficit. Publishing minutes costs little and would settle the unanimity question.
The other side. The Commission maintains that its decisions were unanimous and that written notes are routine in collective bodies. The Supreme Court upheld the SIR, and para 152 does recognise a residual power to adapt documentation for an intensive revision. Reported letters and remarks are not findings; the legality of the Form 6 changes is for the Court to decide. Clean rolls are themselves a constitutional duty under Article 324.
The balanced verdict. The legal questions will be settled in court, but credibility is not a legal question. Whatever the merits of the SIR, a Commission that records its deliberations, explains changes on the record and shows that dissent was considered would be far harder to attack. Transparency serves the ECI’s own interest.
How to Think About This
Collective bodies need collective processes. For any multi-member regulator or commission (ECI, UPSC, SEBI board, Finance Commission), legitimacy depends on regular meetings, circulated agendas, recorded minutes and formal dissent. Use this lens in GS2 answers on institutional reform.
Authority versus legitimacy. The ECI has wide constitutional authority under Article 324; its legitimacy depends on being seen as impartial. Mains answers on constitutional bodies score when they make this distinction.
GS4 angle. Lavasa frames the crisis as one of conscience and accountability: when formal mechanisms such as impeachment are impractical, institutional integrity depends on the ethics of those in office. Link to transparency, probity and the Nolan principles of public life.
Diagram-in-Words
Can the ECI untie knots of its own making? Lavasa’s argument
From the SIR and Form 6 changes, through dissent and court scrutiny, to the remedy the column proposes.
The credibility of the Election Commission of India rests as much on its internal functioning as on its constitutional powers. Discuss in the context of recent controversies over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. (250 words)
The Election Commission of India (ECI), a multi-member body under Article 324, derives its authority from the Constitution and its legitimacy from public trust. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, and the open dissent of two Election Commissioners over it, has strained both.
Constitutional position: Article 324 vests superintendence of rolls and elections in the ECI; T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995) held that the CEC and ECs decide as a body, by majority where they differ; the 2023 Act on appointments also provides for majority decisions. Concerns: the two Election Commissioners’ 14 letters of objection argued, among other things, that Form 6 changes were “illegal and unauthorised”; the ECI first claimed unanimity, then admitted two versions of Form 6, then withdrew a declaration; meetings were reportedly not held for months; ERO access to ECINet was reportedly restricted.
The Supreme Court upheld the SIR on 27 May, but para 152 said the ECI’s residual authority over documentation is not unbounded; on 5 October the CJI reportedly said no modified Form 6 had been approved. Reforms: publish minutes of key decisions, institutionalise regular meetings, record dissent formally, consult political parties before major exercises, and strengthen the independence of appointments.
An election body is trusted when it is seen to deliberate, decide collectively and explain itself; transparency about its own functioning is the quickest route back to credibility.
Interview Angle
"How can a multi-member constitutional body show the public that it works collectively, without exposing every internal disagreement?"
Takeaway Box
- Thesis: the ECI’s SIR troubles are self-inflicted; publishing the minutes of the SIR decision would test its claim of unanimity.
- Form 6: two versions used; declaration withdrawn; the CJI reportedly said on 5 October that no modified Form 6 was approved.
- Para 152 (27 May): a “residual authority” over documentation, but “not unbounded”.
- Dissent: 14 letters by ECs Sandhu and Joshi; no meetings for four months; no minutes for a year; ECINet access denied to EROs.
- Law: Article 324; RP Act 1950, Section 21; T.N. Seshan (1995): decisions by majority.
Revision Flowchart
The ECI, the SIR and Form 6
Covers the constitutional and legal background, the sequence of the dispute, Lavasa’s argument, the counter-view, the way forward and the exam angles.
Sources: The Indian Express, column by Ashok Lavasa, 7 October 2026; background: Ujiyari, 24 September 2026
The Election Commission of India is in an unprecedented bind of its own making over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR). Its shifting explanations on Form 6, the recorded objections of two Election Commissioners and the absence of collective deliberation have eroded public trust; to restore it, the Commission should publish the minutes of the meeting that approved the SIR.
- Criticism comes from citizens, civil society, retired civil servants, former judges, lawyers, political parties and the media; high courts have questioned some ECI decisions, and the Supreme Court has admitted petitions seeking the CEC’s suspension.
- At a hearing on 5 October, the Chief Justice of India reportedly observed that “no modified Form 6 has been approved by us”; an Election Commissioner had called the Form 6 changes “illegal and unauthorised” in a letter of 14 August.
- The ECI’s responses shifted: on 23 September it said all decisions were unanimous; on 26 September it admitted using two versions of Form 6 and said the Supreme Court had upheld the changes; it then withdrew the declaration attached to Form 6.
- Para 152 of the Supreme Court’s 27 May judgment recognised a “residual authority” to frame a documentation regime for the SIR, but said it is “not unbounded” and must respect the statutory scheme.
- The Election Commissioners reportedly complained of no meetings for four months, no agenda or minutes for a year, denial of ECINet access to Electoral Registration Officers, and 16 lakh appeals filed in West Bengal without their knowledge.
The Commission says its decisions are unanimous and that written notes and differing views are a normal part of deliberation; the Supreme Court upheld the SIR on 27 May with safeguards, and its para 152 recognises the Commission’s authority to adapt documentation to an intensive revision. Disputes over internal procedure do not by themselves make the revision unlawful.
Publish the minutes of the ECI meeting that approved the SIR; hold regular meetings with circulated agendas and minutes; place any documentation changes on the record with their legal basis; let the courts rule on legality; and rebuild trust through transparency rather than public statements.
Cite this page: Can the ECI Untie Knots of Its Own Making? Lavasa on SIR — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis