The Lift Line
“Dreaming by a politician is not planning. It privileges charisma over diagnosis, visibility over equity, and legacy over expertise.”
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
Fahad Zuberi, a PhD scholar at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who writes on cities, offers in The Indian Express of 1 October 2026 a sharp post-mortem of the Smart Cities Mission (SCM). Its value for aspirants lies in linking a flagship scheme to a constitutional theme: the weakness of urban local bodies despite the 74th Amendment. It is a critical view; balance it with the mission’s achievements in your answer.
GS Paper 2: Devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein; government policies and interventions. GS Paper 1: Urbanisation, its problems and remedies.
Background and Context
The Smart Cities Mission.
| Feature | Detail |
|---|---|
| Launched | 25 June 2015, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs |
| Cities | 100, chosen through a City Challenge competition |
| Strategy | Area-Based Development (ABD): retrofitting, redevelopment, greenfield; plus pan-city technology solutions |
| Delivery | Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs), companies under the Companies Act, 2013, with the State/UT and the urban local body as promoters |
| Status | The mission has ended (as background, its deadline was extended to 31 March 2025) |
The evidence the author cites.
| Study | Finding |
|---|---|
| Sarbeswar Praharaj (2025) | Interventions reached under 10% of the population across the 100 cities; in 41 cities the ABD area was under 10% of municipal territory and 5% of the population; in Ludhiana, Ahmedabad, Jaipur, about 0.5% of the city got about 20% of investment |
| Bajpai and Biberman (2021) | About 40% of Smart City transport funding went to roads and parking, only 2% to buses |
The constitutional frame. The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992 added Part IXA (Articles 243P to 243ZG) and the Twelfth Schedule (18 functions, including urban planning, roads and bridges, water supply, public health and sanitation, slum improvement).
The Analysis
1. Vagueness as a feature. “Smartness” was undefined, which let governments present very different projects as proof of modernity: an effective public-relations machine.
2. Showcase over coverage. ABD concentrated money in small precincts that could be photographed as transformation; the enclave was then presented as the city.
3. Working around the third tier. SPVs were justified by low municipal capacity, but instead of building that capacity, they bypassed it, reproducing the core weakness of Indian urbanism: fiscally dependent, decision-poor local bodies.
4. A template, not a diagnosis. Chennai’s floods, Surat’s industry, Guwahati’s growth, Jaipur’s heritage and Bengaluru’s mobility needed different answers. Spending skewed to roads, parking and dashboards rather than buses, drains and housing.
5. Citizens as an audience. Drone shots and inaugurations included citizens visually while excluding them from planning. Consultation came after the direction had already been “dreamt”.
6. What works. Ground-up programmes such as Odisha’s Jaga Mission and the alliance of SPARC, NSDF and Mahila Milan were less photogenic but democratic and durable.
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
Smart Cities Mission:
- Launched 25 June 2015; 100 cities via a City Challenge; Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
- Implemented through SPVs under the Companies Act, 2013.
- Strategy: Area-Based Development plus pan-city solutions (for example, Integrated Command and Control Centres).
Urban local government:
- 74th Amendment, 1992: Part IXA, Articles 243P to 243ZG; Twelfth Schedule, 18 functions.
- Article 243W: powers and responsibilities of municipalities (as the State legislature may provide).
- Article 243Y: State Finance Commission reviews municipal finances.
Ground-up example:
- Jaga Mission (Odisha): land rights and upgrading for urban slum dwellers, with community participation.
⚠️ Watch the trap: The Twelfth Schedule (municipalities) has 18 subjects; the Eleventh Schedule (panchayats) has 29. Devolution of these functions is at the discretion of State legislatures.
The Debate
For the author’s view. Evidence on concentration of spending and on bypassing local bodies supports the charge that the mission privileged visibility over equity and local democracy.
The complications. Command centres proved useful during the pandemic and for traffic and emergency management; SPVs brought project-management skills where municipalities lacked them; and competition among cities spurred planning.
The balanced verdict. The mission produced assets but not stronger cities. The next generation of urban policy should channel money through empowered, accountable local bodies, with participatory planning and priority to everyday services.
How to Think About This
Separate the project from the institution. A scheme can build good projects and still weaken the institutions meant to run the city. In any urban question, ask who decides, who pays and who maintains after the ribbon is cut.
Diagram-in-Words
Urban missions in India have often worked around, rather than through, urban local bodies. Critically examine this statement with reference to the Smart Cities Mission and the 74th Constitutional Amendment. (250 words)
The Smart Cities Mission, launched in June 2015 for 100 cities, sought to improve urban infrastructure and services through area-based development and pan-city technology solutions, implemented by special purpose vehicles. As the mission has closed, evaluations point to a recurring problem in Indian urban policy: centrally designed programmes that bypass the elected urban local bodies the Constitution created.
The 74th Constitutional Amendment of 1992 gave municipalities constitutional status, and Article 243W with the Twelfth Schedule listed 18 functions, including urban planning, roads, water supply and slum improvement, that States may devolve to them. In practice, devolution of funds, functions and functionaries remains partial, and municipal finances are weak.
The Smart Cities Mission routed money through special purpose vehicles registered as companies, justified by low municipal capacity, but this created parallel structures and did little to build local capacity. Area-based development concentrated investment in small precincts, so benefits reached a small share of residents, and spending favoured visible items such as roads, parking and command centres over buses, drainage and housing.
Participation was often procedural. At the same time, the mission did create integrated command and control centres, project-management skills and some useful infrastructure, and many municipalities could not have executed large projects alone.
Ground-up programmes such as Odisha’s Jaga Mission, which gave land rights to slum dwellers with community participation, show that durable urban improvement comes from local institutions and residents.
Future urban missions should strengthen rather than bypass urban local bodies: assured fiscal transfers, professional municipal cadres, ward committees and participatory planning, with priorities set by local evidence. Smartness should be measured by everyday services, not by showcase precincts.
Interview Angle
"You are posted as the commissioner of a mid-sized city with a limited budget. Would you invest in a command-and-control centre or in storm-water drains and buses? Justify your choice."
Takeaway Box
- SCM: 2015, 100 cities, ABD and pan-city projects, delivered by SPVs.
- Evidence: under 10% of population reached; 40% of transport money to roads and parking, 2% to buses.
- Core flaw: bypassed urban local bodies (74th Amendment, Twelfth Schedule).
- Better models: Odisha’s Jaga Mission; SPARC, NSDF, Mahila Milan.
- Lesson: aspiration tested against evidence and local knowledge.
Sources: The Indian Express, Smart Cities Mission, Constitution of India, Part IXA
Fahad Zuberi argues that the Smart Cities Mission, now ended, was a politician’s “dream project” that privileged visible showcase enclaves, special purpose vehicles and a national template of “smartness” over local needs, democratic participation and the boring foundations of urban life, and that urban planning must begin in evidence and local knowledge, not in a finished image.
- The vague label of “smartness” made the mission a powerful political narrative that could package very different interventions as proof of modern governance.
- Area-Based Development concentrated money in small precincts: a 2025 study by Sarbeswar Praharaj found interventions reached less than 10% of the population across the 100 cities; in 41 cities the ABD area covered under 10% of municipal territory and 5% of the population, and in Ludhiana, Ahmedabad and Jaipur about 0.5% of the city received about 20% of investment.
- Special purpose vehicles worked as parallel structures to municipalities instead of building their capacity, leaving the third tier weak and fiscally dependent.
- A one-size template ignored local problems (Chennai’s floods, Bengaluru’s mobility, Jaipur’s heritage); a 2021 study by Bajpai and Biberman found about 40% of transport funding went to roads and parking and only 2% to buses.
- Projects that worked better, such as Odisha’s Jaga Mission and the work of SPARC, NSDF and Mahila Milan, grew from the ground up.
The column states no counter-case; the strongest one is this. The mission created integrated command centres that proved useful during the pandemic, built project-management capacity, introduced competition among cities and completed thousands of projects; municipalities often lacked the capacity and credit-worthiness to execute large projects, which is why SPVs were used.
The author: treat aspiration as inquiry tested against evidence, expertise and situated knowledge, and build from the ground up. Ujiyari’s synthesis: devolve funds, functions and functionaries to urban local bodies as the 74th Amendment intended, plan through ward committees and participatory budgeting, and prioritise drainage, affordable housing, public transport and ward-level maintenance.
Cite this page: The Smart Cities Mission Was a Dream, and That Was the Problem: Showcase Enclaves, Bypassed Local Bodies — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis