🗞️ Why in News The Bombay High Court (Justice Milind N. Jadhav), in an order of 18 November 2026, set aside the ICICI Bank Board’s sanction to prosecute former Managing Director Chanda Kochhar under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act). The court held that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), not the Board, is the authority competent to remove a bank’s managing director, so the Board could not grant the sanction. It also quashed the Special CBI Court’s consequential actions and refused the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) an eight-week stay.
The Case So Far
The CBI alleges cheating and irregularities in a Rs 3,250 crore loan that ICICI Bank granted to the Videocon Group in 2012, when Kochhar headed the bank. These are the CBI’s allegations; no court has ruled on them.
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| 8 December 2017 | CBI opens a preliminary enquiry against Kochhar |
| 22 January 2019 | CBI registers an FIR under IPC Sections 420 and 120B and PC Act Sections 7, 13(1)(d) and 13(2) |
| December 2022 | CBI arrests Kochhar and her husband, Deepak Kochhar |
| 9 January 2023 | Bombay High Court orders their release on interim bail |
| 27 March 2023 | CBI writes to ICICI Bank seeking sanction under Section 19 of the PC Act |
| 22 April 2023 | ICICI Bank Board adopts a resolution to grant sanction |
| 15 May 2023 | Sanction to prosecute Kochhar issued by the Board |
| 12 July 2023 | Special Court for CBI, Greater Bombay, takes cognizance (CBI Special Case No. 874 of 2023) |
| 4 December 2023 | Kochhar files the writ petition challenging the sanction |
| 18 November 2026 | Bombay High Court quashes the sanction and the consequential actions |
When the High Court ruled, the trial, in the order’s words, was “at the stage of framing of charge”. Two other Videocon matters run on separate tracks and do not concern this criminal case: the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on the Videocon resolution plan remand, and the NCLT Mumbai order on Venugopal Dhoot’s personal guarantee covered in an earlier roundup.
Why the Board Could Not Grant Sanction
Why the ICICI Bank Board’s sanction failed
Covers the Section 19(1)(c) test, the RBI’s removal power under the BR Act, the two grounds and what the order quashed.
The whole case turned on one phrase in Section 19(1)(c): “the authority competent to remove him from his office”. Kochhar was not a Union or State employee, so the sanction had to come from whoever can remove a private bank’s managing director. Justice Jadhav traced that power through the BR Act:
- Section 36-AA(1): where the RBI is satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest, to protect depositors or to secure the proper management of a bank, it may, for reasons recorded in writing, remove from office a bank’s chairman, director or chief executive officer. The judge concluded: “Thus the power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only.”
- Section 35-B(1)(b): the RBI’s previous approval is needed to terminate the appointment of a managing director or chief executive officer.
- Sections 5-A and 36-AC: the Act overrides a bank’s memorandum, articles and Board resolutions, and Section 36-AC places the RBI’s power above any other law, contract or instrument.
From this the court held that “Board of Directors of ICICI Bank cannot be the authority competent to remove the Petitioner”, so the Board’s sanction document “is not a valid sanction under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act”. The order adds that no statutory provision confers such a power on the Board, and that none was identified in the sanction, the Board resolution or the CBI’s request letter.
The judge also noted what the Board route cost Kochhar. Under Section 36-AA(2), the RBI cannot order removal without giving the person “a reasonable opportunity of making a representation to the Reserve Bank against the proposed order”. As LiveLaw reports the order, the RBI has passed no removal order against her, and her right to make that representation “has been lost altogether”.
The Second Ground: No Application of Mind
The court set the sanction aside on a second, independent ground. A sanctioning authority must look at the evidence before it permits a prosecution; this one, the judge found, did not. In the order’s words: “There is not an ounce of evidence to show that the sanctioning authority considered any material collected by Respondent No.1 [the CBI], if any, in its investigation of Petitioner”. Its conclusion combines both grounds: the authority “is not the Competent Authority and it completely failed to apply its mind to the material”.
Why the Court Ruled Before the Trial
The CBI argued that a challenge to the sanction could be decided only at trial, after evidence, and that the real test is whether there was a failure of justice. The judge held that Section 19(3) and (4) do not bar the High Court, since Section 19(3) applies only to a court sitting in appeal, confirmation or revision, and explained why the defect could not wait:
“Though it is true that trial has not commenced, the very fact that cognizance is taken on the basis of the impugned defective sanction itself nullifies all past and future procedure followed by the Special Court. Nullity of sanction goes to the root of prosecution’s case in proceedings under the PC Act as it is a jurisdictional foundational fact and it would stand on the same pedestal as an absent sanction.”
A sanction from the wrong authority, in other words, is treated as no sanction at all, and a court cannot take cognizance without one.
What the Order Does, and Does Not, Decide
| The order does | The order does not |
|---|---|
| Quash the sanction of 15 May 2023 as “unsustainable in law being a nullity” | Acquit Kochhar or rule on the loan allegations |
| Quash the Special Court’s consequential actions in CBI Special Case No. 874 of 2023 | Say anything about a fresh sanction from the RBI |
| Refuse the CBI’s request for an eight-week stay, sought to challenge the judgment | Direct the Special Court or the CBI on the next step, or deal with any other accused |
Keep one distinction clear. Section 17A of the PC Act requires prior approval before a police officer inquires into a public servant’s decisions; the CBI argued that ICICI Bank had given that approval. The ruling is about the different Section 19 sanction, which a court needs before it takes cognizance.
Mains Lens
Protection and accountability. Sanction exists so that officials are not harassed for honest decisions. The same filter can delay accountability when the wrong body grants it: here a prosecution begun in 2019 has lost its sanction at the threshold of trial, more than three years after cognizance. The lesson for investigators is procedural, not substantive: identify the removing authority before seeking sanction.
The regulator’s place in governance. For a bank’s top management, the BR Act gives the RBI, not shareholders or the Board, the power to remove, and the order links that power to Section 19. The ruling therefore reads banking regulation and anti-corruption law together, a theme that runs across GS2 (accountability of public servants) and GS3 (banking regulation).
Public servant status of bank officers. The prosecution here proceeded under Sections 7 and 13 of the PC Act. The background is Section 46A of the BR Act, which the Supreme Court in Ramesh Gelli held makes a bank’s chairman, managing director and executive director public servants for the PC Act. Where that status applies, so does the sanction requirement, and with it the question of who the competent authority is.
What to watch. CBI counsel sought the eight-week stay to challenge the judgment, and the court declined it. No appeal to the Supreme Court had been reported as of 19 November 2026, and the order is silent on what happens next in the Special Court.
UPSC Relevance
GS Paper 2. Structure and functioning of the judiciary; transparency and accountability; the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and prosecution sanction for public servants.
GS Paper 3. Indian economy: banking sector regulation, the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 and the RBI’s supervisory powers.
A question worth preparing. “Prosecution sanction protects honest officers but can also delay accountability.” Examine with reference to Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and the Bombay High Court’s November 2026 ruling on the competent authority for a private bank’s managing director. (250 words)
The Mains framing. Define sanction and its purpose, explain Section 19(1)(c) and the RBI’s removal power under Section 36-AA, set out both grounds of the ruling, and close on how investigators can avoid such defects.
📌 Facts Corner, Knowledgepedia
Prelims, statement-ready facts:
- Case: Chanda Kochhar v. Central Bureau of Investigation and Anr., Writ Petition No. 6636 of 2024, Bombay High Court.
- Order: 18 November 2026, Justice Milind N. Jadhav (single judge); 57 pages.
- Quashed: ICICI Bank Board’s sanction of 15 May 2023 and the Special Court’s consequential actions.
- Section 19(1)(c), PC Act: sanction from “the authority competent to remove” the public servant.
- Section 36-AA(1), BR Act: the RBI may remove a bank’s chairman, director or chief executive officer.
- Section 36-AA(2), BR Act: a reasonable opportunity to make a representation to the RBI first.
- Section 35-B(1)(b), BR Act: RBI’s previous approval to terminate a managing director or CEO.
- Section 46A, BR Act: deems a bank’s whole-time chairman, MD, directors and employees public servants for Chapter IX, IPC.
- CBI v. Ramesh Gelli (2016): Supreme Court held the Chairman/MD and Executive Director of GTB bank public servants for the PC Act.
Prelims, the traps:
- The order quashes a sanction; it does not acquit Kochhar or decide the loan allegations.
- Section 17A (approval to inquire) and Section 19 (sanction for a court to take cognizance) are different.
- The removing authority for a bank’s managing director is the RBI, not the bank’s Board, as this order held.
Mains, arguments and keywords:
- Keywords: previous sanction, competent authority, application of mind, failure of justice, jurisdictional fact.
- Sanction filters frivolous cases but a defective one can undo years of prosecution at the threshold.
- Way forward: identify the removing authority first; a sanctioning body should show it considered the evidence.
Interview, be ready for:
- “Is this a loophole for the accused?” No: it enforces the statute’s own rule on who may sanction.
- “Should private bankers need sanction at all?” Section 46A, read with Ramesh Gelli, treats them as public servants, so Section 19 applies.
Sources: Bombay High Court, Chanda Kochhar v. Central Bureau of Investigation and Anr., order of 18 November 2026 (PDF, via LiveLaw), LiveLaw (18 November 2026), Bar & Bench (18 November 2026), The Hindu (print, 19 November 2026), Supreme Court of India, CBI v. Ramesh Gelli, judgment of 23 February 2016, PRS, Banking Regulation Act, 1949.
Cite this page: Chanda Kochhar Sanction Quashed: Section 19 PC Act and RBI — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Current Affairs