The Lift Line

“Perhaps the next innovation in UPI should therefore be as bold as the first: Not simply how we move money, but how we price the infrastructure that moves it.”

Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam

Balakrishnan Mahadevan, a former Chief Operating Officer of the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) who also worked with the World Bank’s Payment System Development Group, writes in The Indian Express of 1 October 2026. Two weeks before the merchant discount rate (MDR) on UPI begins, he argues against its design, not its existence. We explained the new MDR framework and the Supreme Court challenge in our 29 September deep dive; this column gives the strongest insider case for a different pricing model.

GS Paper 3: Indian economy, banking, payments and digital infrastructure; inclusive growth. GS Paper 2: Government policies and interventions.

Background and Context

What changes on 15 October 2026 (NPCI circular of 15 September).

Payment Charge
Person-to-person (P2P) Free
Person-to-merchant (P2M) up to Rs 2,000 Free
P2M above Rs 2,000 0.4%, capped at Rs 300
Essential services (railways, telecom, fuel and others) Flat Rs 5
Small merchants receiving up to Rs 1 lakh a month Exempt

How India priced its other payment rails (as the author describes).

System Type Pricing
NEFT Credit transfer RBI’s former maximums: Rs 2.50 up to Rs 10,000; Rs 5 up to Rs 1 lakh; Rs 15 for Rs 1-2 lakh; Rs 25 above Rs 2 lakh (the author simplifies this to Rs 5 and Rs 25)
RTGS Credit transfer Rs 25 for Rs 2-5 lakh; Rs 50 above
IMPS (NPCI, real-time) Credit transfer 2016: public-sector bank charges above Rs 1,000 capped at NEFT levels
Cards Pull transaction, merchant-initiated Percentage of value (MDR)

The Analysis

1. UPI is a push, not a pull. In a credit transfer, the payer instructs the bank to send money. In a card payment, the merchant pulls money from the cardholder’s account or credit line after authorisation. Different mechanics justify different pricing.

2. India has its own pricing tradition. Every Indian credit-transfer system has used simple fixed or slab charges with low maximums. Why should UPI, built to escape card economics, adopt a percentage model?

3. The cost is small. NPCI’s cost was about 9.8 paise per transaction across its payment systems in 2024-25, on an IIM Bangalore analysis, and about 5 paise on the author’s narrower operational basis excluding marketing. The wider ecosystem has other costs, but how much revenue is genuinely needed for sustainability?

4. Purpose over revenue. UPI is digital public infrastructure (DPI): a small merchant accepting Rs 50 or a migrant sending money home represents participation in the formal economy, not just a transaction.

Data and Institutions Vault

Prelims-grade facts:

UPI and NPCI:

  • NPCI: set up in 2008 by the RBI and the Indian Banks’ Association; a not-for-profit company.
  • UPI launched in 2016; NPCI processed about 230.2 billion transactions across systems in 2024-25 (IIM Bangalore analysis).
  • Background: zero MDR on UPI and RuPay debit cards began on 1 January 2020.

The new framework:

  • MDR 0.4% on P2M payments above Rs 2,000, cap Rs 300, from 15 October 2026.
  • Legal basis: Section 10A, Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007, now protecting only notified modes.

⚠️ Watch the trap: The MDR is paid by the merchant, not the customer; it is shared among the acquiring bank, the issuing bank, app providers and the network.

The Debate

For the author’s view. Percentage pricing imports card-network logic into a public credit-transfer rail; slab pricing would recover costs while keeping UPI cheap and inclusive.

The complications. Banks and apps bear costs well above NPCI’s; zero MDR depended on government incentives that have shrunk; the new framework already exempts P2P, payments up to Rs 2,000 and small merchants; and a cap of Rs 300 limits the charge on large payments.

The balanced verdict. The debate is about the shape of the fee. Publishing ecosystem-wide cost data and reviewing the framework after a year would let evidence decide between capped percentages and slabs.

How to Think About This

Price public infrastructure by its purpose. For a public good, ask what the price is for: cost recovery, investment, or rationing. Then choose a structure (flat, slab, percentage) that serves that aim without excluding the users the infrastructure exists for.

Diagram-in-Words

UPI: credit transfer like NEFT, RTGS, IMPS Cards: pull, % fee different economics NPCI cost about 5 to 10 paise 0.4% MDR from 15 October card logic on a public rail Author’s ask: slab pricing with low caps
If UPI’s design broke from card economics, its pricing can too: cost recovery through simple slabs, not a percentage of value.
✍️ Mains Answer Framework
Question

Digital public infrastructure must be financially sustainable without losing its inclusive purpose. Examine the debate on merchant charges for UPI payments in this light. (250 words)

The Unified Payments Interface, operated by the National Payments Corporation of India since 2016, is India’s flagship digital public infrastructure. From 15 October 2026, merchant payments above Rs 2,000 will carry a merchant discount rate of 0.4 per cent, capped at Rs 300, with exemptions for small merchants, person-to-person transfers and low-value payments, ending the zero-MDR regime that began in January 2020.

The case for a fee rests on sustainability. Banks and payment service providers bear costs for infrastructure, fraud prevention, security and customer support, and government incentives that replaced the MDR have not kept pace with volumes.
A fee on larger merchant payments, which mostly involve businesses able to pay, can fund investment and reliability. The case for caution rests on purpose and design.
UPI is a credit-transfer system like NEFT, RTGS and IMPS, which India has always priced through fixed or slab-based charges with low maximums, rather than a card network priced as a percentage of value. Cost data suggest that the network’s own cost per transaction is a few paise, so a percentage fee could exceed cost recovery for large payments, and merchants may pass it on or steer customers back to cash.
Pricing also affects inclusion, competition between payment modes and the international adoption of UPI as a public good. Legal questions about who fixes the charge, now before the Supreme Court, add to the need for transparency.

UPI’s pricing should be as deliberate as its design: transparent, based on published costs, protective of small merchants and low-value payments, and reviewed periodically. Whether fixed slabs or a capped percentage, the principle must be cost recovery for a public rail, not a new revenue pool.

Interview Angle

"UPI processes billions of transactions free of charge to users. Who should pay for this public infrastructure: the taxpayer, the merchant, the user or the banks?"

Takeaway Box

  • New fee: 0.4% MDR above Rs 2,000, cap Rs 300, from 15 October 2026.
  • Argument: UPI is a credit transfer; price it like NEFT/RTGS/IMPS slabs.
  • Cost: about 9.8 paise per transaction (5 paise excluding marketing).
  • Purpose: DPI for participation, not a revenue pool.
  • Counter: ecosystem costs exceed NPCI’s; exemptions already protect small users.

Sources: The Indian Express, NPCI, RBI

Key Arguments at a Glance

Balakrishnan Mahadevan argues that UPI, a home-grown credit-transfer rail built to reduce dependence on card networks, should not adopt the card networks’ percentage-of-value pricing; India should price it like its other credit-transfer systems (NEFT, RTGS, IMPS), with simple, fixed or slab-based charges and low maximums, in keeping with its purpose as digital public infrastructure.

Supporting
  • UPI, like RTGS, NEFT and IMPS, is a credit transfer in which the payer pushes money; a card payment is a pull transaction initiated by the merchant, with different economics.
  • India’s credit-transfer systems have used fixed or slab charges with caps: the author cites NEFT maximums of Rs 5 up to Rs 1 lakh and Rs 25 above, and RTGS maximums of Rs 25 for Rs 2-5 lakh and Rs 50 above; in 2016 IMPS charges by public-sector banks were capped at NEFT levels.
  • An IIM Bangalore analysis of NPCI’s 2024-25 accounts put total expenses at Rs 2,270 crore for 230.2 billion transactions across NPCI’s systems, about 9.8 paise a transaction; on the author’s narrower operational-cost basis, excluding marketing, it is about 5 paise.
  • UPI was built as digital public infrastructure to widen participation in the formal economy; technology is the means, and inclusion and human capability the purpose.
Counter

The column states no counter-case; the strongest one is this. Banks, payment apps and acquirers bear costs well beyond NPCI’s (fraud management, customer support, merchant acquisition, security), and years of zero MDR and shrinking government incentives have left the ecosystem underfunded; a small percentage fee on larger merchant payments, with exemptions for small merchants and payments up to Rs 2,000, is a modest correction.

Way Forward

The author asks that UPI be priced on its own terms, with simple slabs and maximums. Ujiyari’s synthesis: design UPI pricing for cost recovery and sustainability, not revenue maximisation: consider slab-based fees with low caps, publish cost data across the ecosystem, keep small merchants and low-value payments free, and review the framework once data on its effects are available.

Cite this page: UPI Was an Innovation; Its Fee Should Be One Too: The Case for Slab Pricing Instead of a 0.4% MDR — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis