The Lift Line

“Manufacturing in India has not emerged as an engine of mass employment, unlike in the development trajectory of Asian economies such as Korea and China.”

Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam

The Indian Express’s unsigned editorial of 2 October 2026 reads the Annual Survey of Industries (ASI) 2024-25, released on 30 September and summarised in our 1 October roundup. It turns a data release into the central GS3 question: growth versus jobs.

GS Paper 3: Indian economy and issues relating to growth, development and employment; industrial policy.

Background and Context

Indicator Figure Source cited
Registered manufacturing output growth, 2024-25 7.8% ASI
Employment growth, 2024-25 7.2% ASI
Emoluments growth, 2024-25 12.08% ASI
Persons engaged Over 2 crore in 2024-25; 1.72 crore in 2021-22 ASI
Non-farm workers in informal-sector enterprises 73.1% PLFS 2025
Organised vs unorganised manufacturing jobs, 2023-24 About 1.9 crore vs 3.3 crore Economic Survey

What the ASI covers. The ASI, conducted by the National Statistics Office (MoSPI), covers factories registered under the Factories Act, 1948 (10 or more workers with power, 20 or more without), bidi and cigar establishments, and certain electricity units. It does not cover unorganised manufacturing.

The Analysis

1. Healthy, but narrow. The formal sector is growing: output, employment and wages all rose in 2024-25. But it employs only a fraction of the workforce.

2. Capital over labour. Wages per worker have grown slower than net profit, output per worker has stayed roughly flat, and invested capital has risen steadily. Growth is coming more from capital than from hiring and productivity.

3. The small-firm problem. Organised manufacturing is dominated by small firms, though bigger factories (over 100 workers) employ more people, pay higher wages and are more productive, the Economic Survey notes.

4. No ladder out of farming. Without factory jobs, the low-skilled and unskilled either stay on the farm or take up gig work. The editorial calls this “India’s employment challenge”.

Data and Institutions Vault

Prelims-grade facts:

ASI 2024-25:

  • Output +7.8%, employment +7.2%, emoluments +12.08% in registered manufacturing.
  • Persons engaged: over 2 crore (1.72 crore in 2021-22).
  • Conducted by NSO, MoSPI, under the Collection of Statistics Act, 2008.

Labour data:

  • PLFS 2025: 73.1% of non-farm workers in informal-sector enterprises.
  • PLFS is conducted by the NSO; it replaced the NSSO’s quinquennial employment surveys in 2017.

⚠️ Watch the trap: The ASI covers only registered factories; the IIP measures monthly production volume. A rise in ASI employment says nothing about the far larger unorganised manufacturing workforce.

The Debate

For the editorial’s view. Successive governments’ efforts have not moved manufacturing’s share of GDP or employment much; the dual structure persists.

The complications. Formal jobs did rise sharply; automation means today’s factories need fewer workers than 1980s Korea or 2000s China; services and construction also absorb labour.

The balanced verdict. The question is not whether to grow manufacturing but which manufacturing: labour-intensive sectors and firms that can scale.

How to Think About This

Watch the ratios, not the totals. Output, jobs and wages can all grow while wages per worker lag profits and output per worker stagnates. Those ratios tell you whether growth is inclusive.

Diagram-in-Words

Formal output +7.8% jobs +7.2%, 2 crore Capital over labour small firms dominate 73.1% informal farm or gig work Lever: labour-intensive sectors, firms that scale skills linked to clusters
Formal manufacturing is growing, but too capital-heavy and too small-firm to absorb the workforce; the lever is the job content of growth.
✍️ Mains Answer Framework
Question

Why has manufacturing in India not become an engine of mass employment, as it did in East Asia? Suggest measures to make manufacturing growth more job-intensive. (250 words)

The Annual Survey of Industries 2024-25 shows registered manufacturing output growing 7.8 per cent and employment 7.2 per cent, with persons engaged crossing 2 crore. Yet the Periodic Labour Force Survey 2025 finds 73.1 per cent of non-farm workers in informal-sector enterprises, and manufacturing’s share of GDP and of employment has barely moved.

Several factors explain why manufacturing has not absorbed labour as in Korea or China. First, capital intensity: invested capital has risen steadily while output per worker is flat and wages lag profits, suggesting growth driven by capital rather than by mass hiring.
Second, firm size: organised manufacturing is dominated by small units, while larger factories, which employ more people at higher wages and productivity, remain few; regulatory thresholds and credit constraints discourage firms from growing. Third, a dual structure: in 2023-24 about 1.9 crore worked in organised manufacturing against about 3.3 crore in the unorganised segment, where productivity and wages are low.
Fourth, skills and location: workers leaving agriculture lack industrial skills, and industrial clusters lack housing and infrastructure. The result is that the low-skilled stay on farms or move to gig work.
Incentive schemes need to be weighted more towards labour-intensive sectors like apparel, footwear, toys and food processing, which also need trade access, logistics and simpler compliance.

India’s manufacturing problem is not growth but its job content. Implementing the labour codes, helping small firms scale, prioritising labour-intensive sectors and linking skilling to cluster demand can turn healthy output growth into the mass employment a young workforce needs.

Interview Angle

"Factories are adding capital faster than workers. Is that a problem for a country with a young labour force, or simply modernisation?"

Takeaway Box

  • ASI 2024-25: output +7.8%, jobs +7.2%, emoluments +12.08%; over 2 crore engaged.
  • But: 73.1% of non-farm workers in informal enterprises (PLFS 2025).
  • Why: capital deepening, small firms, flat output per worker.
  • Result: low-skilled workers stay on farms or turn to gig work.

Sources: The Indian Express, MoSPI, ASI 2024-25

Key Arguments at a Glance

The Indian Express argues that India’s formal manufacturing is growing at a healthy pace, as the Annual Survey of Industries 2024-25 shows, but it has not become an engine of mass employment; most workers remain informal, leaving the low-skilled with farm work or gig work.

Supporting
  • In 2024-25 registered manufacturing output grew 7.8%, employment 7.2% and emoluments 12.08%, but wages per worker grew slower than net profit, output per worker barely changed and invested capital kept rising.
  • Persons engaged in organised manufacturing crossed 2 crore in 2024-25, up from 1.72 crore in 2021-22, yet 73.1% of non-farm workers were in informal-sector enterprises according to the PLFS 2025.
  • In 2023-24, about 1.9 crore people worked in organised manufacturing against about 3.3 crore in the unorganised segment, according to the Economic Survey.
  • Organised manufacturing is dominated by small firms, although larger factories (over 100 workers) employ a larger share of workers, pay more and are more productive.
Counter

Ujiyari’s synthesis: formal manufacturing jobs did rise faster than in many past years, services and construction are absorbing labour, and capital deepening raises productivity that can fund higher wages over time; the case that manufacturing alone must absorb the workforce may be outdated in an era of automation.

Way Forward

The editorial diagnoses rather than prescribes. Ujiyari’s synthesis: help firms grow past the small-firm trap (labour code implementation, easier compliance), back labour-intensive sectors such as textiles, footwear, food processing and electronics assembly, link skilling to industry demand, and improve urban infrastructure and worker housing near industrial clusters.

Cite this page: Industry Is Growing, but Isn't Creating Jobs: ASI 2024-25 — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis