The Lift Line
“This does not justify a blanket exemption, which could overlook environmental impacts; nor should institutions be left without a way to bring existing development into compliance.” (Kalaiselvan Periyasamy, The Hindu, 19 November 2026)
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
In the news: on 19 November 2026, Kalaiselvan Periyasamy argued in The Hindu that the Union Environment Ministry should issue a statutory notification that gives eligible educational campuses built without prior environmental clearance a route to compliance.
The column is an argument, not a report of an event; its byline describes the author as “an environmental and social expert”. It joins two lines of Supreme Court decisions usually studied apart: whether large educational buildings need prior environmental clearance (EC), and whether a project begun without EC can be cleared afterwards.
GS Paper 3: conservation, environmental pollution and degradation, environmental impact assessment. GS Paper 2: government policies and their design; the limits of delegated legislation, and judicial review of notifications and office memoranda. Prelims: the EIA Notification, 2006, section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, the Vanashakti judgments, Article 142 and the environmental principles the Court relied on. Essay: development and environment.
Earlier on Ujiyari:
- The Supreme Court’s judgment on ex post facto green clearances (30 July 2026)
- The roundup item on pending post-facto clearance proposals (2 October 2026)
The Crux in 60 Words
Large educational buildings need prior EC: the Supreme Court struck down their exemption in August 2025. Clearance after the fact is now closed to fresh applicants: the Court’s final Vanashakti judgment barred new applications. Campuses caught in between have no route. Periyasamy asks the Ministry to use the one opening the Court left: a narrow statutory notification.
Kalaiselvan Periyasamy argues that the Environment Ministry should issue a statutory notification, within the limits the Supreme Court has set, that lets eligible educational campuses built without prior environmental clearance come into compliance.
- The author says Supreme Court judgments have confirmed that large educational buildings need prior environmental clearance, after the Kerala High Court and then the Supreme Court set aside the exemptions given to schools, colleges and hostels.
- The author says the Supreme Court’s final Vanashakti judgment closed the ex post facto route to fresh applicants, so an institution that never applied has no procedure left.
- The author says older universities hold clearances that do not cover every building, and planning bodies and Pollution Control Boards now ask for clearance before any new building or approval.
- The author says expansion of classrooms, laboratories and hostels is continuous, and delay restricts opportunities for students.
A route for campuses that built without clearance may reward non-compliance and invite other sectors to ask for the same, and the line between deliberate and unintended violations is hard to draw in practice.
A narrow, time-bound notification under section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, covering only eligible campuses, with environmental scrutiny, damage assessment, proportionate compensation, remediation and personal accountability for the officials responsible.
Background and Context
Strand one: are campuses covered at all?
The EIA Notification, 2006 brought large construction projects within prior EC, and the author says this was the first time a built-up-area test applied to educational institutions. The column traces what followed. In December 2014 the Union government exempted schools, colleges and institutional hostels, subject to environmental management conditions. Counsel before the Supreme Court in 2025 dated that notification 22 December 2014 and said the Kerala High Court set it aside in 2024.
The Centre then issued a fresh exemption, and the NGO Vanashakti challenged it:
- 29 January 2025: Note 1 to Entry 8(a) of the Centre’s notification exempted industrial sheds, schools, colleges and hostels from prior EC.
- The stay: the Supreme Court first stayed the notification’s operation on Vanashakti’s petition.
- 5 August 2025: a Bench of Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justice K. Vinod Chandran quashed Note 1 as arbitrary (2025 INSC 961).
As LiveLaw reported the Court’s reasoning: “If any construction activity of an area more than 20000 sqm is carried out, it will naturally have an effect on the environment, even if the building is for educational purpose.” Large educational buildings were back within prior EC.
Strand two: can a violator ever be cleared afterwards?
The second strand concerns projects that started or finished without EC, and began in 2017: a notification of 14 March 2017 opened a one-time window for such “violation” projects, and an Office Memorandum (OM) of 7 July 2021 set out how they would be handled. The author describes these as mechanisms for environmental appraisal, damage assessment, remediation and payment of environmental compensation.
The case then turned on itself:
- 16 May 2025 (Vanashakti-I): a Bench of Justices Oka and Bhuyan struck down both instruments, holding, in the later judgment’s words, “the grant of an ex post facto EC to be alien to environmental jurisprudence”.
- 18 November 2025: on review petitions, including one by CREDAI (named in the judgment as the Confederation of Real Estate Developers of India), a Bench allowed review by 2:1, with Justice Bhuyan dissenting, and recalled Vanashakti-I.
- 20 January 2026: the Environment Ministry, by an OM recorded in the final judgment, directed that pending applications under the 2017 Notification and the 2021 OM be processed, with the final grant subject to the Court’s orders.
- 29 July 2026 (the final judgment): a Bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and Vipul M. Pancholi, in a judgment written by Justice Bagchi (2026 INSC 761; 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1404), settled the matter.
What the final judgment held
- Prior EC is mandatory: unless amended by an appropriate notification, the 2006 regime “would not accommodate grant of post facto EC”.
- The 2017 Notification is valid, being “narrowly tailored and time-bound delegated legislation traceable to Section 3 of the 1986 Act”.
- The 2021 OM is quashed, prospectively, because it “supplants an earlier delegated legislation through an administrative instruction, which is impermissible in law”, violating Articles 14 and 21.
- No fresh applications: future ex post facto EC only “by way of a valid notification in exercise of powers under section 3 of the 1986 Act”.
- What survives: ECs already granted; pending applications, which “shall be taken to their logical conclusion”; and the Court’s own Article 142 power “in appropriate cases”.
Where the strands meet, in the author’s account
In this context, the author points to an Office Memorandum that, by the author’s account, the Ministry issued on 30 September 2026 and which “reiterates that only pending applications may proceed”. On the author’s reading, an institution that put up a building of more than 20,000 square metres without applying earlier now has no way to obtain EC. The author adds that most older universities run by the Union and State governments do not hold ECs covering every building raised over decades, and that planning authorities, local bodies and Pollution Control Boards insist on EC for new buildings, revised planning permission and regularisation.
The Analysis
The diagnosis holds on the judgment’s own terms. The final judgment draws a clean line: what was granted stays, what was pending is decided, and nothing new may enter under the 2017 or 2021 instruments. A campus that never applied falls on the wrong side of that line, whatever the merits of its building. The author’s point is not that the Court erred; it is that the Ministry has not yet used the room the Court left.
The remedy the author asks for is the one the Court described. The judgment does not “place a clog on the power of the Central Government to issue an appropriate narrowly tailored amnesty notification in supervening public interest as an exception to the 2006 Notification”. It goes further: the Centre has “ample power under Section 3 to issue appropriate notifications formulating amnesty schemes with regard to such classes or categories of non-compliant projects whose sustainability is necessary to subserve larger public interest.” The author’s proposal, a notification for “eligible educational campuses”, fits that description: a class of projects, chosen for public interest, through section 3 rather than an office memorandum.
The form matters as much as the content. The 2017 Notification survived as narrow, time-bound delegated legislation; the 2021 OM fell as an administrative instruction. A campus scheme has to be a notification with a closing date and a defined class.
The Court has already weighed public buildings. It made its ruling prospective partly because projects already under way included the AIIMS Medical College and Hospital building in Odisha, the Centre of Excellence for Cancer Diseases in Tamil Nadu and “several medical colleges”. Educational and health buildings in public hands are the kind of case the Court had in view.
Accountability is the part the column underplays. The author asks the scheme to separate deliberate violations from developments “undertaken without any intention to violate”. The Court asked for something sharper: future amnesty schemes “should provide effective deterrent measures against individual public servants, including disciplinary action and personal liability for environmental damage”. Since many of the campuses in question are run by the Union and State governments, a scheme without personal accountability would let the officials who approved the buildings escape.
Two cautions on the column’s framing. First, the threshold point for educational buildings comes from the August 2025 judgment on the exemption; the final Vanashakti judgment is about projects that began without EC, not about the threshold. Second, the column calls the Ministry’s September 2026 instrument an Office Memorandum; whatever its form, the final judgment already says that any new route must come by notification under section 3.
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
The law:
- EP Act, 1986: Act No. 29 of 1986, dated 23 May 1986; section 3 empowers the Centre to protect and improve the environment.
- EIA Notification, 2006: S.O. 1533, 14 September 2006, under sections 3(1) and 3(2)(v) of the EP Act and Rule 5(3) of the EP Rules, 1986.
- EIA Notification, 1994 (27 January 1994) first required environmental clearance.
- Item 8 of the 2006 Schedule: building and construction projects; townships and area development projects.
- Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Act, 2023: graded civil penalties replaced criminal prosecution, effective 1 April 2024.
The cases:
- Vanashakti v. Union of India, 29 July 2026: 2026 INSC 761; 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1404.
- Bench: CJI Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi (author) and Vipul M. Pancholi.
- Held: 2017 Notification (14 March 2017) valid; 2021 OM (7 July 2021) quashed prospectively, under Article 142.
- Vanashakti-I (16 May 2025, 2025 INSC 718) recalled on review, 18 November 2025, by 2:1 (2025 INSC 1326).
- 5 August 2025 (2025 INSC 961): CJI B.R. Gavai, Justice K. Vinod Chandran quashed Note 1 to Entry 8(a) of the 29 January 2025 notification.
Principles the Court relied on:
- M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987): absolute liability.
- Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action (1996): polluter pays.
- Vellore Citizens’ Welfare Forum (1996): precautionary principle.
- M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath (1997): public trust doctrine.
The traps:
- The final Vanashakti judgment UPHELD the 2017 Notification; the May 2025 ruling that struck it down was recalled.
- Ex post facto EC is not barred for ever: a narrow amnesty notification under section 3, and Article 142 orders, remain possible.
- The 20,000 sq m point on campuses comes from the August 2025 judgment (2025 INSC 961), not the final Vanashakti one.
- ECs already granted stay valid; pending applications go to a “logical conclusion”.
The Debate
The case for the author’s line. A university that cannot add a laboratory because an old hostel lacks clearance helps no one, and the planning bodies’ insistence on EC compounds the problem with every new approval. The author asks for the law to be used, not bent: the Court itself named public-interest classes as the proper subject of a notification.
The other side. Every amnesty teaches that compliance is optional. The 2017 window was meant to be one-time; a campus window would be a second, and builders, hospitals and industrial units may ask for a third. The precautionary principle and the polluter pays principle, both relied on by the Court, point to prevention rather than regularisation. And the line between “deliberate” and “unintended” violations is hard to draw for public bodies that are expected to know the law.
The balanced verdict. A narrow, closing-dated notification for eligible educational campuses can fit the judgment, if it carries what the Court asked for: damage assessment, compensation, remediation and personal accountability for officials. The more lasting fix is upstream: no building plan for a large campus should be approved before its EC.
How to Think About This
For any question on regularising a past violation (buildings, mining, industry), run four tests drawn from the judgment:
- Form: is it a notification under section 3 of the EP Act, or an office memorandum? Only the first can carve an exception to the 2006 Notification.
- Scope: is the class narrow and defined by public interest, as with the eligible campuses the author has in mind, or open to all?
- Time: is the window one-time and closing, like the 2017 Notification?
- Cost to the violator: damage assessment, compensation, remediation, and personal liability for the officials responsible.
The judgments and notifications are the record; the claim that campuses deserve a scheme, and its design, are the author’s argument.
Diagram-in-Words
Large campus building → prior EC needed? Yes, since the August 2025 judgment → built without EC? → applied under 2017 or 2021 before the bar? Yes: the application goes to a logical conclusion. No: no route today → the author’s proposal: a section 3 notification for eligible campuses, with damage assessment, compensation and remediation.
Read it top to bottom: the column is about the last two boxes, where an institution that never applied now stands.
Prior environmental clearance is mandatory under the EIA Notification, 2006, yet many institutions have expanded without it. In the light of recent Supreme Court judgments, discuss how the law can balance environmental accountability with the need to expand educational infrastructure. (250 words)
The EIA Notification, 2006 makes prior environmental clearance (EC) mandatory for listed projects, including large building and construction projects. Two lines of Supreme Court decisions now bear on educational campuses: one on whether large educational buildings are covered, and one on whether a project begun without EC can ever be cleared afterwards.
Coverage. On 5 August 2025 the Supreme Court (2025 INSC 961) struck down Note 1 to Entry 8(a) of the Centre’s notification of 29 January 2025, which had exempted industrial sheds, schools, colleges and hostels, reasoning that construction beyond 20,000 square metres affects the environment whatever the building is used for.
Ex post facto EC. In Vanashakti v. Union of India (29 July 2026, 2026 INSC 761) the Court held prior EC mandatory, upheld the one-time 2017 Notification as narrowly tailored and time-bound delegated legislation, quashed the 2021 Office Memorandum with prospective effect for supplanting a notification by an administrative instruction, and barred fresh applications. Pending applications go to a logical conclusion, and ECs already granted stand.
The gap. A campus that built without applying has no procedure, which stalls further approvals.
The opening. The Court left the Centre power to issue a narrowly tailored amnesty notification under section 3 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, for classes of projects whose sustainability serves larger public interest, and asked that future schemes carry deterrence, including personal liability of public servants.
Risks. Any scheme must respect the precautionary and polluter pays principles and must not become a standing amnesty.
A notification for eligible campuses, time-bound, with damage assessment, compensation, remediation and personal accountability, would fit both the law and the need to expand education. Prevention matters more: building plans should not be approved without prior EC in the first place.
Interview Angle
"A government university built a large hostel without environmental clearance and now cannot expand. Would you let it regularise the building, and how would you do it without rewarding violators?"
Takeaway Box
- Core idea: prior EC is mandatory and fresh ex post facto applications are barred, so campuses built without EC have no route until the Centre issues a narrow notification.
- Prelims hooks: EIA Notification 2006 (S.O. 1533); EP Act section 3; Vanashakti (2026 INSC 761); 2017 Notification upheld, 2021 OM quashed prospectively; 2025 INSC 961 on the campus exemption.
- Mains frame: form (notification, not OM), scope (narrow class), time (one-time), cost (compensation and personal liability).
- Probable question: “Ex post facto environmental clearance is alien to environmental jurisprudence. Critically examine in the light of recent Supreme Court judgments.” (GS3, 250 words)
Sources:
- Kalaiselvan Periyasamy, “A regulatory fix for India’s campuses”, The Hindu, 19 November 2026
- Supreme Court of India, Vanashakti v. Union of India, judgment of 29 July 2026, 2026 INSC 761; SCC Online report, 31 July 2026
- LiveLaw, 5 August 2025, and Verdictum, 13 August 2025, on the Supreme Court’s judgment of 5 August 2025 (2025 INSC 961)
- EIA Notification, S.O. 1533, 14 September 2006; Environment (Protection) Act, 1986
Cite this page: Environmental Clearance: A Regulatory Fix for Campuses — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis