The Lift Line
“Where you draw the line decides how much economic insecurity you see.” (Saumitra Bhaduri, The Hindu, 17 November 2026)
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
In the news: on 17 November 2026, The Hindu op-ed “A poverty line that falls short” asked why researchers and policymakers cannot agree on how many Indians are still poor, though all agree that poverty has fallen sharply over the past decade.
The column closes with its author’s description: “Saumitra Bhaduri is Professor at the Madras School of Economics”. The argument below is the author’s. It reads the World Bank’s latest India figures, which use three international lines in 2021 PPP terms, against India’s own estimates. This site’s 20 October editorial on the World Bank’s poverty figures set out the background and the three lines; this page takes up the question that piece left open: why the estimates disagree, and what an official line should do.
GS Paper 3: Indian economy; inclusive growth and issues arising from it. GS Paper 2: issues relating to poverty and hunger; welfare of vulnerable sections. The theme also serves the Essay paper (measurement and inequality) and the Interview.
The Crux in 60 Words
Poverty in India has clearly fallen, but estimates of who is still poor run from about 5% to more than 26%. Bhaduri shows that most of the gap comes down to the lines themselves; the method used and a decade without usable survey data add to it. A country aiming to be high-income needs a new official line.
Saumitra Bhaduri argues in The Hindu that the fall in Indian poverty is not in doubt, but the count of who is still poor depends on where the line is drawn and how it is built, so India needs a new official line.
- At the World Bank’s $3.00 line poverty is in low single digits; at its $4.20 line, on the same data, it is several times higher. Only the yardstick changes.
- Domestic estimates split by method: an old line updated for inflation gives single-digit poverty, while the study the author cites, which rebuilds the Rangarajan method from the new survey, reports 26.4%.
- The 2017-18 consumption survey was never released, so for more than a decade the debate had no official consumption-based anchor.
- Consumption misses deprivation, and NITI Aayog’s multidimensional figure for 2022-23 is a projection, not a fresh survey result.
Several lines can be a strength, not a failure: a low line tracks destitution and higher lines track insecurity. A single official line can turn into a political target, and the decline itself is not in dispute.
Set a new official line from the latest consumption data, publish the method, and report it beside multidimensional measures and a higher line that shows how many can live decently.
Background and Context
How India has drawn its poverty line
| When | Body | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| 1979 | Alagh Task Force | Separate calorie norms for rural and urban populations (as the column recounts) |
| Later | Lakdawala Committee | State-specific poverty lines and price indices (as the column recounts) |
| Constituted December 2005; report December 2009 | Expert Group chaired by Prof. Suresh D. Tendulkar | Dropped the direct calorie method for a wider consumption basket that counts spending on health and education |
| 22 July 2013 | Planning Commission press note (Tendulkar method) | 2011-12 lines of Rs 816 (rural) and Rs 1,000 (urban) per person per month; poverty 21.9% (rural 25.7%, urban 13.7%) |
| Constituted June 2012; report June 2014 | Rangarajan Expert Group | Higher 2011-12 lines of Rs 972 (rural) and Rs 1,407 (urban); poverty 29.5% (rural 30.9%, urban 26.4%) |
The Planning Commission’s own note records why the review came: “several representations were made suggesting that the Tendulkar Poverty Line was too low”.
The data gap
The column’s second cause is the missing survey. In November 2019 MoSPI decided not to release the 2017-18 Consumer Expenditure Survey results, citing data quality issues. The next survey, the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) 2022-23, ran from August 2022 to July 2023; its factsheet came out in February 2024 and the full report in June 2024. A second survey followed for August 2023 to July 2024.
The World Bank’s three lines (2021 PPP)
| Line, per person per day | What it marks | India, 2022 | India, 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3.00 | International extreme poverty line | 5.25% | 2.57% |
| $4.20 | Lower-middle-income line | 23.89% | 16.12% |
| $8.30 | Upper-middle-income line | 82.06% | 79.98% |
The column dates its 2.6% to 2022-23. In the World Bank’s platform data (PIP) the 2.57% is the 2023 figure, and the 2022 figure at the same line is 5.25%. The column’s “same country, same year” point holds either way: 2.6% and 16.1% are both 2023 figures.
The Analysis
The column makes its case in six steps.
1. The yardstick decides the count. At $3.00 a day only a small share of Indians is poor; at $4.20 the share jumps. “Same country, same year. Only the yardstick changed.” The author’s point is that a low level of extreme poverty does not mean poverty has stopped being a major issue. For an answer, this is the key distinction: extreme poverty measures destitution, while higher lines measure insecurity.
2. Domestic estimates split on the line, then on the method. The author cites SBI Research, which takes the Tendulkar line, adjusts it for inflation and gets 7.2% rural and 4.6% urban poverty for 2022-23. For context, SBI Research’s note of 27 February 2024 gives those figures on updated lines of Rs 1,622 (rural) and Rs 1,929 (urban) a month; the rupee lines the column quotes, ₹1,632 and ₹1,944, are slightly higher. The author also cites a study by Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024) that rebuilds the Rangarajan method from the latest survey and, on lines of ₹2,515 and ₹3,639, reports 26.4%; a third estimate, on an inflation-adjusted Rangarajan line, falls in between. “Higher lines, higher poverty.” Then method: one camp adjusts an old line for prices, the other rebuilds the line from spending in the new survey. “Both have limitations, and they are answering different questions.”
3. International lines compare; they do not price needs. PPP dollar lines show where India stands among countries, but, the column notes, they are not built on a basket of what basic needs cost in India. That is why, in the author’s reading, the $3.00 figure sits near the low domestic estimates and the $4.20 figure near the high ones.
4. History explains the dispute. India moved from calorie norms to a broader consumption basket. The Tendulkar method put 2011-12 poverty at 21.9%; critics thought its thresholds too low, and the Rangarajan group’s higher lines gave 29.5% for the same year. Two expert estimates for the same year set the pattern the column describes today.
5. A decade without an anchor. With the 2017-18 survey withheld, “India argued about poverty without an official consumption-based number to anchor the argument”. Researchers worked with assorted lines, price indexes and reconstructed estimates. HCES 2022-23 gave fresh data, but not yet an agreed line.
6. Consumption misses part of the picture. The multidimensional index counts deprivation in health, education and living standards, including sanitation, drinking water and housing. NITI Aayog’s report of July 2023 records a fall from 24.85% in 2015-16 to 14.96% in 2019-21. NITI’s later paper projects 11.28% for 2022-23 by applying the earlier rate of decline, which the column rightly calls “a projection from earlier trends, not the result of a fresh survey”. The author cites higher multidimensional estimates from the World Bank (15.5%) and from the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (16.4% for 2019-21).
The closing point. The author finds the World Bank’s most telling figure elsewhere: about 80% of Indians lived below the $8.30 upper-middle-income line in 2023. The column adds that per capita income per day is more than three times that line and concludes that “A low extreme-poverty count is masking deep inequality.” Note that this sets national income against survey consumption: the World Bank’s platform puts India’s mean consumption in 2023 at about $6.65 a person a day, below the $8.30 line.
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
World Bank lines (2021 PPP, per person per day):
- Extreme poverty $3.00; lower-middle-income $4.20; upper-middle-income $8.30
- India 2023: 2.57% below $3.00, 16.12% below $4.20, 79.98% below $8.30
- India 2022: 5.25% below $3.00; 23.89% below $4.20
- India 2011: 57.68% below $4.20
- India 2023: mean consumption about $6.65 a day; Gini index 23.0 (consumption)
Expert groups:
- Tendulkar Expert Group: constituted December 2005, report December 2009; wider basket with health and education spending
- Tendulkar, 2011-12: lines Rs 816 rural, Rs 1,000 urban a month; poverty 21.9% (rural 25.7%, urban 13.7%)
- Tendulkar, 2011-12: 26.93 crore poor (Planning Commission press note, 22 July 2013)
- Rangarajan Expert Group: constituted June 2012, report June 2014
- Rangarajan, 2011-12: lines Rs 972 rural, Rs 1,407 urban; poverty 29.5% (rural 30.9%, urban 26.4%); 36.3 crore poor
Surveys:
- 2017-18 Consumer Expenditure Survey: not released (MoSPI, November 2019, data quality)
- HCES 2022-23: August 2022 to July 2023; average MPCE Rs 3,773 rural, Rs 6,459 urban
- HCES 2023-24: August 2023 to July 2024; average MPCE Rs 4,122 rural, Rs 6,996 urban
- SBI Research, 27 February 2024: 2022-23 poverty 7.2% rural, 4.6% urban, updated Tendulkar lines Rs 1,622 and Rs 1,929
Multidimensional poverty (NITI Aayog):
- National MPI: A Progress Review 2023 (PIB, 17 July 2023): 24.85% (2015-16) to 14.96% (2019-21), NFHS-4 to NFHS-5
- Rural 32.59% to 19.28%; urban 8.65% to 5.27%; MPI value 0.117 to 0.066
- 12 indicators in three equally weighted dimensions: health, education, standard of living
- Discussion paper (January 2024): 29.17% (2013-14) to 11.28% (2022-23), both estimated; about 24.82 crore escaped poverty
The traps:
- 2.57% (about 2.6%) is the World Bank’s 2023 point at $3.00; its 2022 point is 5.25%.
- 16.1% is poverty at $4.20, not extreme poverty and not an Indian official line.
- NITI’s 11.28% for 2022-23 and 29.17% for 2013-14 are projections, not survey results.
- 26.4% was Rangarajan’s urban ratio for 2011-12; the all-India ratio was 29.5%.
- Tendulkar (21.9%) and Rangarajan (29.5%) are estimates for the same year, 2011-12.
The Debate
The author’s case. The fall in poverty is real, but a number that swings from about 5% to more than 26% with the choice of line cannot guide policy. India’s own lines are old or disputed, international lines were built for comparison, and the projected multidimensional figure is not a measurement. A country that wants to be high-income, the author writes, needs to know “how many can live decently”, not only how many escaped extreme poverty.
The other side. Three objections. First, several lines can be read as a strength: a low line measures destitution and a higher one measures vulnerability, and both are useful. Second, a single official line becomes a political number, attacked by every side, as the Tendulkar line was. Third, the column itself opens by saying there is “no serious doubt” that poverty has fallen sharply, so the question of direction is settled even if the level is not.
The balanced verdict. The direction is settled; the level and its meaning are not. An official line matters less for the headline than for targeting: who gets a ration card, a housing grant or a cash transfer. The useful answer is a line built from current spending, published with its method, and read beside a higher line and a multidimensional measure.
How to Think About This
Use the “line, method, data, dimension” lens on any poverty number:
- Line: how high is it, and what is it meant to capture (survival or a decent life)?
- Method: is it an old line carried forward by prices, or rebuilt from today’s spending?
- Data: which survey and which year, and is it a measurement or a projection?
- Dimension: spending alone, or deprivations in health, education and living standards too?
Two estimates that differ on any of these four are not in conflict; they answer different questions. Say which question you are answering before you quote a figure.
Diagram-in-Words
Choose a line (low: destitution; high: insecurity) → choose a method (update an old line, or rebuild from the new survey) → apply it to a survey (HCES 2022-23, after the unreleased 2017-18 survey) → add dimensions (MPI: health, education, living standards) → the case for one transparent official line.
Read it left to right: each step adds a source of difference, which is why the estimates diverge.
Estimates of poverty in India vary widely with the poverty line and the method used. Discuss the reasons for this divergence and suggest how India should frame a new official poverty line. (250 words)
The Planning Commission’s estimates of 22 July 2013 put poverty in 2011-12 at 21.9% on the Tendulkar method; the Rangarajan Expert Group (2014) put it at 29.5% on higher lines. Estimates since then all show a decline, but they disagree on its level because they use different lines, methods and data.
First, the level of the line. The World Bank’s data for 2023 (2021 PPP) show 2.57% of Indians below $3.00 a day, 16.12% below $4.20 and 79.98% below $8.30: one survey, three answers.
Second, the method. One approach updates an old line for inflation: SBI Research (February 2024) used the Tendulkar line, updated to Rs 1,622 rural and Rs 1,929 urban a month, and found 7.2% rural and 4.6% urban poverty in 2022-23.
The other rebuilds the line from the spending pattern in the new survey, which yields higher lines and higher poverty. Third, purpose.
International lines are set in PPP dollars to compare countries, not to price a basket of basic needs in India. Fourth, data.
The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation did not release the 2017-18 consumption survey, citing data quality; the Household Consumption Expenditure Surveys of 2022-23 and 2023-24 resumed the series. Fifth, dimensions.
NITI Aayog’s Multidimensional Poverty Index fell from 24.85% (2015-16) to 14.96% (2019-21), but its 11.28% for 2022-23 is a projection. Consumption lines also miss deprivations in health, education and living standards.
India needs a transparent, basket-based official line built from current survey data, with State lines and a clear updating rule. It should be read beside multidimensional measures and a higher line of decent living, so that policy tracks both destitution and economic insecurity.
Interview Angle
"The World Bank's data show extreme poverty in India below 3% in 2023, yet about four in five Indians below its upper-middle-income line. Which of these numbers should guide policy, and why?"
Takeaway Box
- Core idea: the decline in poverty is settled; how many remain poor depends on the line, the method and the data.
- Prelims hooks: World Bank lines $3.00, $4.20, $8.30 (2021 PPP); Tendulkar 21.9% and Rangarajan 29.5% for 2011-12; NITI MPI 24.85% to 14.96%; 11.28% projected.
- Mains keywords: head-count ratio, PPP lines, consumption basket, inflation-adjusted versus rebuilt lines, multidimensional deprivation, decent living.
- Ethics and Interview angle: is a low poverty count a success to announce, or a reason to raise the bar?
- Probable question: “Distinguish between consumption poverty and multidimensional poverty. Why does India need both measures?” (GS3, 150 words)
Sources:
- “A poverty line that falls short”, Saumitra Bhaduri, The Hindu, 17 November 2026
- World Bank: Poverty and Equity Briefs, Annual Meetings 2026; PIP data for India (2021 PPP)
- Planning Commission: press note on poverty estimates for 2011-12, 22 July 2013
- Report of the Expert Group to Review the Methodology for Measurement of Poverty (Rangarajan), June 2014
- PIB: NITI Aayog’s National Multidimensional Poverty Index: A Progress Review 2023, 17 July 2023
- NITI Aayog: discussion paper “Multidimensional Poverty in India since 2005-06”, January 2024
- SBI Research: note on HCES 2022-23, 27 February 2024
- MoSPI: HCES 2022-23 factsheet; HCES 2023-24 press note
Cite this page: Poverty Line That Falls Short: India's Poverty Estimates — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis