The Lift Line

“Legality is not the only form of justice.”

Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam

This column in The Indian Express of 7 October 2026 is by Shibashis Chatterjee, professor at Jadavpur University. It reads the failed execution of Christa Pike in the US state of Tennessee as proof that “humane” execution is a myth, and asks what a constitutional state may do once a death sentence has been tried and has failed.

For Indian aspirants, the column arrives some seven weeks after the Supreme Court, in Rishi Malhotra v. Union of India (2026), dismissed a plea to replace hanging with lethal injection. Read together, the two raise every core question of the death-penalty debate: method, dignity, deterrence, delay and abolition. The idea that Article 21 protects dignity even at the end of life also runs through our earlier piece on the right to die with dignity.

GS Paper 2: Fundamental rights (Article 21); judiciary; pardoning powers of the President and Governor. GS Paper 4: Ethics in public institutions; retributive versus reformative justice; human dignity.

Background and Context

What happened in Tennessee

Point Detail
Who Christa Pike, Tennessee’s only woman on death row, convicted of the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer
When Execution attempted on 30 September 2026
What Given two doses of pentobarbital; survived and was taken to hospital, where doctors worked to save her; reported unconscious and on a ventilator
Since Her attorneys said on 6 October that she was conscious and speaking but faces a long recovery; they have gone to court to preserve evidence from the attempt

Earlier “survivors” of execution in US law

Case What happened What the court held
Francis v. Resweber (1947) Louisiana’s electric chair malfunctioned in 1946; Willie Francis survived A botched execution was an accident, not a separate punishment; a second attempt was allowed
Frankfurter’s caveat Concurring opinion “A series of abortive attempts” might raise a different constitutional problem
Later rulings Challenges to lethal-injection protocols The Eighth Amendment (cruel and unusual punishment) does not guarantee a painless death

India: how the law on execution stands

Point Position
Method Hanging: “hanged by the neck till he is dead” (Section 354(5) CrPC, now Section 393(5) BNSS 2023)
Deena Dayal v. Union of India (1983) Three-judge Bench upheld hanging as consistent with Article 21
Rishi Malhotra v. Union of India (2026 INSC 873) Judgment of August 2026 by Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta: PIL dismissed; no material showing lethal injection has any added advantage over hanging; no reason to refer Deena Dayal to a larger Bench; future scrutiny on new scientific or medical evidence, and an expert body set up by the Union, not ruled out
Centre’s stand Its affidavit, highlighted at a hearing in October 2025, said giving prisoners a choice of method was not practically feasible

The Analysis

1. Two faces of the modern state. In one place, authorities apply chemicals intended to cause death; in another, doctors employ their expertise to preserve the same life. If Pike recovers, the author asks: “Can the state then prepare to execute someone its medical system has just fought to save?”

2. Not a plea for sympathy. Pike’s crime was appalling, and no serious discussion should diminish Colleen Slemmer’s suffering or disregard the claims of victims and their families. The moral challenge of the death penalty arises precisely because the crimes are often so horrific. The real question is: “What can a constitutional state do once guilt is confirmed?”

3. The Frankfurter warning. In 1947, the US Supreme Court let Louisiana try again on Willie Francis. But Frankfurter’s caveat about “a series of abortive attempts” deserves renewed attention. The deeper question is whether bringing a person to death’s door more than once changes the very nature of the punishment.

4. No unlimited licence. A court may impose death, but “the state does not automatically gain an unlimited licence to keep trying to cause death until it succeeds.” Punishment includes the actual suffering imposed: the fear of death, invasive treatment, deadly chemicals, emergency care, and then the whole ordeal again. A second attempt is a different experience from the punishment originally declared.

5. Foucault and the invisible execution. In Discipline and Punish, Michel Foucault traced how punishment moved from public spectacle of bodily suffering to something bureaucratic, regulated and increasingly invisible. Lethal injection is that journey’s end point: sovereign violence disguised as clinical peace. “Pike’s survival shreds that clean, polished facade.”

6. Medicine against execution. Lethal injection owes its acceptance partly to medicalisation: the prisoner lies on what looks like a hospital gurney. But “medicine and execution have utterly opposite moral foundations.” Medicine intervenes to preserve life or ease suffering; execution can only remove a life.

7. The myth of the painless death. The US Supreme Court has ruled that the Eighth Amendment does not ensure a painless death, so prisoners face a tough standard when contesting execution protocols. Yet Pike’s case is not only about faulty needles or wrong doses. The question is whether any institution built to kill can attain the moral standing of a routine medical procedure.

8. The global trend. By the close of 2025, 113 countries had abolished capital punishment for all offences, while the US carried out 47 executions that year, its highest total since 2009. The state’s monopoly on legitimate violence exists to replace personal revenge with impartial justice; by ending a life deliberately, the author argues, the state risks mirroring that inflexibility and forecloses remorse, restoration or remedy.

9. Restraint as strength. The law will probably permit Tennessee to try again. But “legality is not the only form of justice.” A constitutional state that has tried and failed to end a life lawfully should acknowledge the limits of its authority, since sovereignty can also be shown through restraint: knowing when and how to stop.

Data and Institutions Vault

Prelims-grade facts:

India:

  • Method of execution: hanging, under Section 393(5) BNSS (earlier Section 354(5) CrPC); the judge must record special reasons for a death sentence (Section 393(3) BNSS).
  • Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980): death penalty constitutional but only in the “rarest of rare” cases.
  • Mithu v. State of Punjab (1983): struck down the mandatory death sentence under Section 303 IPC.
  • Deena Dayal v. Union of India (1983): hanging upheld; reaffirmed in Rishi Malhotra v. Union of India (2026).
  • Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014): inordinate, unexplained delay in deciding mercy petitions is a ground for commutation.
  • Pardoning power: Article 72 (President, including death sentences and court-martial) and Article 161 (Governor; may commute a death sentence but not pardon it).
  • Law Commission, 262nd Report (2015): abolition for all crimes except terrorism-related offences and waging war.
  • Last executions in India: March 2020 (four convicts in the 2012 Delhi gang-rape and murder case, Tihar Jail).

World:

  • 113 countries abolitionist for all crimes by end-2025; the US carried out 47 executions in 2025, the most since 2009.

⚠️ Watch the trap: The Governor can pardon, remit or commute most sentences under Article 161, but only the President can pardon a death sentence (Article 72). And the 2026 Supreme Court judgment upheld hanging; it did not order a switch to lethal injection.

The Debate

For the author’s view (abolition, or at least restraint). Every method of execution, however clinical, involves the state deliberately killing a person, and botched attempts show that “humane” is a label, not a fact. The irreversibility of death rules out correcting judicial error. Studies have found little evidence that the death penalty deters better than life imprisonment. Most of the world has moved away from it, and India’s own Law Commission recommended abolition for ordinary crimes in 2015.

The other side (retention). For the gravest crimes, many citizens and victims’ families see the death penalty as the only proportionate response. India already confines it to the rarest of rare cases, with layers of review: High Court confirmation, Supreme Court appeal, review and curative petitions, and mercy petitions. On method, the Supreme Court found in 2026 that lethal injection is not shown to be more humane than hanging, and Pike’s case in fact supports that conclusion.

The balanced verdict. The method debate matters less than the questions behind it: who gets sentenced to death, after what kind of trial, and how long they wait. India’s practical priorities are rigorous sentencing (including mitigation investigation, as the Supreme Court required in Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2022), time-bound disposal of mercy petitions, and an informed public debate on the Law Commission’s recommendation.

How to Think About This

Theories of punishment. Retributive (deserved suffering), deterrent (preventing future crime), reformative (changing the offender) and restorative (repairing harm). The death penalty serves only the first two, and its deterrent value is contested. In GS4 answers, contrast Kant’s retributivism with the saying often attributed to Gandhi, “an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind”, and the reformative ideal in Indian jail reforms.

Dignity runs through the process. Indian courts have read Article 21 to protect dignity until the very end: the right to a fair trial, protection against solitary confinement, and humane treatment on death row. Pike’s case shows why the manner and the aftermath of execution are not mere technicalities.

Use the case as an example. In an essay or ethics answer on the limits of state power, Pike’s failed execution is a vivid illustration that a lawful act can still raise questions of justice. Pair it with the Indian position: hanging upheld in 2026, but the door left open to fresh evidence and an expert review.

Diagram-in-Words

Argument map

The Christa Pike case: the myth of humane execution

Shibashis Chatterjee’s argument, from the failed execution to the restraint the column asks of the state.

30 September 2026: Tennessee’s attempt fails Christa Pike survives two doses of pentobarbital and is rushed to hospital Two faces of the state one applies chemicals to kill; the other uses medicine to save the same life Opposite foundations medicine preserves life; execution can only end it Medicalisation shattered Foucault: punishment became invisible; Pike’s survival shreds the facade No unlimited licence no "unlimited licence to keep trying", says the author; Frankfurter (1947) warned of "a series of abortive attempts" what it exposes The myth of humane execution collapses can an institution built to kill be a routine medical procedure? Global backdrop 113 countries abolitionist by end-2025; 47 US executions in 2025, the most since 2009 "Legality is not the only form of justice" a state that tried and failed should show restraint
The author’s chain of reasoning: a failed lethal injection forces the state to save the person it tried to kill, the claim of humane execution collapses, and sovereignty can also be shown through restraint.
✍️ Mains Answer Framework
Question

"No method of execution can make the taking of life humane." In the light of this statement, examine the debate on the mode of execution and the retention of the death penalty in India. (250 words)

On 30 September 2026, Tennessee’s attempt to execute Christa Pike by lethal injection failed; she survived and was rushed to hospital. The case exposes the myth that any method of execution can be humane, and revives the question of what a state may do after a failed execution.

Arguments: (1) execution has moved from public spectacle to clinical invisibility (Foucault), but medicine and execution rest on opposite moral foundations; (2) botched attempts raise the question Frankfurter flagged in Francis v. Resweber (1947), whether repeated attempts amount to a different punishment; (3) global trend: 113 countries abolitionist for all crimes by end-2025. India: hanging under Section 354(5) CrPC, now Section 393(5) BNSS; Deena Dayal (1983) upheld it; in Rishi Malhotra v. Union of India (2026) the Supreme Court found no material showing lethal injection had any added advantage over hanging, while leaving room for future scrutiny and an expert body.
Safeguards: rarest of rare (Bachan Singh, 1980), mandatory death struck down (Mithu, 1983), delay as a ground for commutation (Shatrughan Chauhan, 2014), mercy under Articles 72 and 161. Law Commission (262nd Report, 2015) recommended abolition except for terrorism-related offences and waging war.
Counter: deterrence, victims’ rights, public opinion. Ethics: retributive versus reformative justice; dignity in death as part of Article 21.

Whatever the method, the death penalty asks the state to do what medicine forbids. India should keep strengthening sentencing safeguards, consider the Law Commission’s path to abolition, and remember that a state’s strength can also lie in restraint.

Interview Angle

"Should India abolish the death penalty, or is it a necessary deterrent for the rarest of rare crimes? Give a balanced view."

Takeaway Box

  • Thesis: Christa Pike’s survival exposes “humane” execution as a myth; a constitutional state should know when to stop.
  • US law: Francis v. Resweber (1947) allowed a second attempt, with Frankfurter’s warning on “a series of abortive attempts”.
  • Numbers: 113 countries abolitionist by end-2025; 47 US executions in 2025, the most since 2009.
  • India: hanging under Section 393(5) BNSS; upheld in Deena Dayal (1983) and Rishi Malhotra (2026); rarest of rare since Bachan Singh (1980).
  • Reform path: Law Commission’s 262nd Report (2015): abolish except for terror offences and waging war.

Revision Flowchart

Revision flowchart

The Christa Pike case and the death penalty

Covers the case, the argument, the data, the debate, the way forward and the exam angle for India.

The Christa Pike case and the myth of humane execution Shibashis Chatterjee, The Indian Express, 7 October 2026 (GS2, GS4) The case Who Christa Pike, convicted of the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer 30 September 2026 two doses of pentobarbital; she survived and was taken to hospital US law Francis v. Resweber (1947): second attempt allowed; Frankfurter’s caveat The argument Two faces the state kills and saves the same person Foucault from public spectacle to clinical invisibility Medicine vs execution opposite moral foundations Restraint "legality is not the only form of justice" The data Abolition 113 countries abolished for all offences by end-2025 US 47 executions in 2025, highest since 2009 Eighth Amendment does not guarantee a painless death The debate Author’s view "humane" is a label, not a fact; death is irreversible Retention gravest crimes; rarest of rare; layers of review On method Supreme Court 2026: lethal injection not shown to be more humane than hanging Way forward Sentencing rigorous sentencing, including mitigation investigation (Manoj, 2022) Delay time-bound disposal of mercy petitions Debate informed public debate on the Law Commission’s recommendation Exam angle: India Method hanging, Section 393(5) BNSS (earlier 354(5) CrPC); Deena Dayal (1983); Rishi Malhotra (2026) Safeguards Bachan Singh (1980) rarest of rare; Mithu (1983); Shatrughan Chauhan (2014) Trap Governor cannot pardon a death sentence (Art 161); 2026 ruling upheld hanging Reform Law Commission 262nd Report (2015): abolish except terror and waging war
Revision flowchart: the whole column on one screen. Read each band left to right, then cover the facts and recall them from the headings.

Sources: The Indian Express, column by Shibashis Chatterjee, 7 October 2026; PBS NewsHour, 6 October 2026; Rishi Malhotra v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 873 (Verdictum)

Key Arguments at a Glance

Tennessee’s failed attempt to execute Christa Pike, who survived two doses of pentobarbital and was then rushed to hospital to be saved, exposes the myth of “humane” execution: medicine exists to preserve life, execution only to end it, and the clinical setting of lethal injection merely hides the violence of the state.

Supporting
  • The case sets two faces of the modern state against each other: one administers chemicals to kill, the other uses medicine to save the same person.
  • In Francis v. Resweber (1947), the US Supreme Court allowed Louisiana a second attempt on Willie Francis after its electric chair malfunctioned in 1946, but Justice Felix Frankfurter warned that “a series of abortive attempts” might raise an altogether different constitutional problem.
  • A court may impose death, but the state does not thereby gain an unlimited licence to keep trying until it succeeds; a repeat ordeal changes the character of the punishment itself.
  • Foucault showed how punishment moved from public spectacle to bureaucratic invisibility; lethal injection is the end point, and its acceptance rests on medicalisation that Pike’s survival shatters.
  • By the end of 2025, 113 countries had abolished the death penalty for all offences, while the US carried out 47 executions in 2025, its highest yearly total since 2009.
Counter

Pike’s crime, the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, was appalling, and victims and their families have legitimate claims to justice. The US Supreme Court has held that the Eighth Amendment does not guarantee a painless death, and the law may well permit Tennessee to try again.

Way Forward

Legality is not the only form of justice; a constitutional state that has tried and failed to end a life lawfully should recognise the limits of its authority and show restraint. For India, the debate on the mode of execution should be read with the larger questions of sentencing, delay and abolition.

Cite this page: Christa Pike Case Exposes the Myth of Humane Execution — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis