The Lift Line
“Paradoxically, atmanirbharta, which involves designing, developing, testing and manufacturing the platform, constitutes the most expensive acquisition method.”
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
Ajai Shukla, a retired Army officer and defence journalist, challenges a consensus that is rarely questioned: that self-reliance is always the right goal. For GS3 answers on defence indigenisation, it supplies the counter-argument and a practical middle path. It also bears on our earlier editorial on private defence manufacturers, which focused on capital and competition.
GS Paper 3: Security challenges and their management; indigenisation of technology and developing new technology; defence production and exports; industrial policy.
Background and Context
The slogans and the policy.
| Initiative | Year |
|---|---|
| Make in India | 2014 (launched 25 September) |
| Atmanirbhar Bharat and Vocal for Local | 2020 |
| Defence Acquisition Procedure (DAP) | 2020: “Buy (Indian-IDDM)”, indigenously designed, developed and manufactured, is the top category |
| Positive indigenisation lists | From 2020: items the forces must buy from Indian sources after set dates |
The numbers.
| Indicator | Figure (source) |
|---|---|
| Defence production, 2025-26 | Rs 1.78 lakh crore, a record, up from Rs 1.54 lakh crore in 2024-25 (Defence Ministry) |
| Defence production, 2014 | About Rs 46,000 crore (the author) |
| Defence exports, 2025-26 | Rs 38,424 crore, up 62.66 per cent from Rs 23,622 crore (Defence Ministry; the column prints Rs 38,434 crore) |
| Export target | Rs 50,000 crore by 2028-29 (the Defence Minister, as the author reports) |
| Private sector share of production, 2025-26 | About 24 per cent (Defence Ministry) |
| Global standing | Fifth-largest spender; second-largest importer after Ukraine (the author, citing international rankings) |
The acquisition cost hierarchy the author describes, cheapest first.
| Method | Example |
|---|---|
| Lease for the period needed | India’s lease of the nuclear submarine INS Chakra from Russia (2012-2021) and of MQ-9B drones from the US (2020) |
| Buy off the shelf | Direct import of a finished platform |
| Licensed production | Buying technology and building in India, as with the Su-30MKI at HAL |
| Indigenous design and development | Tejas light combat aircraft; the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA) under development |
The Analysis
1. Nobody disputes the goal, which is the problem. Given India’s reliance on imports, any call to indigenise seems beyond argument, and critics risk being accused of serving foreign arms makers.
2. Autarky is expensive. Up to 40 per cent of the cost of “Indian” platforms, including the Tejas, naval warships and many tactical missiles, goes to imported materials, components and systems. Developing every element at home would raise costs unacceptably.
3. The world’s best do not try. Leading defence manufacturers keep control of key technologies and buy the rest from established specialists. About 50 to 55 per cent of the world’s combat aircraft use ejection seats from Britain’s Martin-Baker, including the F-35.
4. Know what is critical. The Tejas’s edge is its manoeuvrability, from an unstable design controlled by a quadruplex digital fly-by-wire flight control system. India developed that software and is extending it to the Tejas Mark 2 and the AMCA. That, the author argues, is the kind of technology self-reliance should target.
5. Project management is the key skill. Deciding what to develop, what to source, and when to close a project will decide whether atmanirbharta is financially viable.
6. Interdependence deters. Embargoes can be deterred by making Indian firms important links in the global supply chains of foreign manufacturers, creating mutual vulnerability. And a middle power dependent on imported oil cannot be fully self-sufficient anyway.
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
Production and exports:
- Defence production 2025-26: Rs 1.78 lakh crore (record); 2024-25: Rs 1.54 lakh crore.
- Defence exports 2025-26: Rs 38,424 crore, up 62.66 per cent; 2024-25: Rs 23,622 crore.
- Private sector share of production in 2025-26: about 24 per cent.
Policy:
- DAP 2020: Buy (Indian-IDDM) is the highest-priority category.
- Positive indigenisation lists: first issued in 2020 by the Department of Military Affairs.
Platforms:
- Tejas: light combat aircraft designed by the Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA), built by HAL.
- AMCA: fifth-generation fighter programme led by ADA.
⚠️ Watch the trap: the record export figure for 2025-26 is Rs 38,424 crore (Defence Ministry); some reports print it as Rs 38,434 crore.
The Debate
For the author’s view. Selective indigenisation gives most of the strategic benefit at a fraction of the cost and time, and supply-chain integration is a better shield against embargoes than autarky.
The complications. Foreign dependence has cost India repeatedly: sanctions, delayed deliveries and spares shortages, as with Russian supplies after 2022. The cost premium of indigenisation buys jobs, an industrial base and exports, which help recover development costs. And the line between “critical” and “non-critical” shifts: engines were once treated as buyable, and delays in foreign engine supplies have held up the Tejas programme.
The balanced verdict. Adopt selective self-reliance: map critical technologies (engines, seekers, radars, flight control, secure communications) at the start of each programme, invest in them at home, buy mature sub-systems abroad, discipline project management, and pursue co-development and exports to make India indispensable in supply chains.
How to Think About This
Separate the platform from its critical technologies. A question on self-reliance is sharper if you distinguish what gives the platform its combat edge or strategic leverage from what is commodity. Self-reliance in the former is strategy; in the latter it can be waste.
Diagram-in-Words
Self-reliance in defence production is a strategic necessity but an economic challenge. Critically examine India's approach to defence indigenisation and suggest how it can be made both effective and affordable. (250 words)
India has long been among the largest importers of arms. Since 2014, policies such as Make in India, the positive indigenisation lists and the Defence Acquisition Procedure 2020, with its preference for indigenously designed equipment, have raised domestic defence production to a record Rs 1.78 lakh crore in 2025-26 and exports to Rs 38,424 crore.
The strategic case for self-reliance is strong: freedom from embargoes and supplier leverage, assured supply of spares and ammunition in war, and an industrial base that creates jobs and exports. But the economic case has limits.
Designing and developing a platform from scratch is the costliest and slowest way to acquire it; leasing, buying and licensed production are cheaper and faster. No major defence economy makes everything: even advanced fighter programmes use foreign ejection seats, engines or avionics.
Indigenous platforms such as the Tejas still import a substantial share of their value. The sensible path is selective self-reliance.
Each programme should identify at the outset the technologies that confer combat advantage or strategic leverage, such as flight control software, seekers, engines and radars, and develop those at home, while sourcing mature sub-systems from specialists. Strong project management, realistic timelines and the willingness to close failing projects are essential.
Deeper participation in global supply chains, through offsets, joint ventures and exports, creates mutual dependence that deters embargoes. Private sector participation, testing infrastructure and research funding complete the ecosystem.
Atmanirbharta should mean control over critical technologies, not autarky. A selective, well-managed approach can deliver strategic autonomy at a cost India can sustain.
Interview Angle
"Should India aim to make every part of its fighter jets at home? Where would you draw the line between self-reliance and buying from abroad?"
Takeaway Box
- Paradox: atmanirbharta is the costliest acquisition route.
- Record: production Rs 1.78 lakh crore, exports Rs 38,424 crore (2025-26).
- Reality: up to 40 per cent of “Indian” platforms is imported content.
- Model: keep critical tech (Tejas fly-by-wire), source the rest (ejection seats).
- Shield: supply-chain interdependence, not autarky.
Sources: The Indian Express, PIB, defence production 2025-26, PIB, defence exports 2025-26
Ajai Shukla argues that complete defence self-reliance is the most expensive way to acquire weapons, that even the leading defence economies buy many sub-systems from specialists, and that India should identify and master only the critical technologies in each platform, manage projects well, and use its place in global supply chains as a deterrent against embargoes.
- The cost hierarchy in defence acquisition runs from leasing (cheapest and quickest) to buying off the shelf, to licensed production, to indigenous design and development (costliest).
- India was the world’s fifth-largest defence spender last year and the second-largest arms importer after Ukraine, the author writes, while domestic defence production rose from about Rs 46,000 crore in 2014 to Rs 1.78 lakh crore in 2025-26.
- As much as 40 per cent of the cost of “Indian” platforms such as the Tejas fighter goes on imported materials, components and systems.
- About 50 to 55 per cent of the world’s combat aircraft use Martin-Baker ejection seats; developers seldom design their own.
- The Tejas’s quadruplex digital fly-by-wire flight control system, developed at home and now being extended to the Tejas Mark 2 and AMCA, shows where self-reliance truly counts.
Dependence on foreign suppliers has repeatedly exposed India to sanctions, delays and spares shortages, as with Russian equipment after 2022; the cost premium of indigenisation buys strategic autonomy, jobs and an industrial base; and exports now help recover development costs.
Identify critical technologies at the start of each programme and develop them at home, source mature sub-systems from global leaders, strengthen project management and the discipline to close failing projects, and integrate Indian firms into global defence supply chains to create mutual dependence.
Cite this page: The Paradox of Defence Atmanirbharta: Self-Reliance Is the Costliest Way to Buy a Weapon — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis