Polity & Governance
Q1. In September 2026 the Supreme Court used Article 142 to quash FIRs against students who protested over the NEET (UG) 2026 paper leak, and barred fresh FIRs. Was this complete justice or judicial overreach?
[For: Judiciary, separation of powers, students and the state]
Position (P): The order has two limbs and they deserve different answers. Quashing the existing FIRs did complete justice to students who were victims of the leak before they were protesters. The bar on future FIRs is harder to defend, because it works like a prospective amnesty, which is normally a legislative or executive act.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Critics point out that in Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India (1998) the Court held that Article 142 cannot override an express statutory provision, and Lalita Kumari (2014) made registration of an FIR mandatory where information discloses a cognisable offence. Supporters reply that a chilling effect spread across several States could be lifted only by a court with national reach.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The order was pronounced on 1 September 2026 by a Bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant. It covered protests between 20 and 25 July 2026 over the leak of NEET (UG) 2026, which was held on 3 May 2026 for over 22 lakh candidates and then cancelled. One Delhi Police FIR against 2,873 persons at Jantar Mantar was expressly carved out, and the Union Government was directed to pay compensation within three months to families of students who died by suicide.
Link to governance (L): The deeper failure lies upstream. The Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 already existed when the leak occurred, so the gap is enforcement. As an administrator I would focus on the chain of custody of papers, digital question delivery and a more autonomous, audited testing agency, so that courts are not left to clean up after the system fails.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Can a High Court pass a similar order? (It can quash proceedings under Section 528 of the BNSS, 2023, the successor to Section 482 CrPC, but only within its territorial limits; Article 142 belongs to the Supreme Court alone.)
- What is the National Testing Agency’s status? (An autonomous body under the Ministry of Education.)
- What did the K. Radhakrishnan committee recommend? (A hybrid or multi-stage NEET and digital question papers.)
Coach Tip: Separate the two limbs before giving a view; the board is testing whether you can defend part of a judgment and question another part without sounding partisan.
Q2. The Centre has proposed a new Article 371(K) for Ladakh. Would a special provision serve Ladakh better than the Sixth Schedule its leaders have sought?
[For: Federalism, tribal safeguards, border regions]
Position (P): A tailored special provision can protect land, jobs and culture in Ladakh while respecting the Union’s security needs on a sensitive border. Its value depends on what it contains and whether it gives people a real democratic voice.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Ladakh’s leaders have sought Sixth Schedule protection and statehood, and many see a special provision as a substitute that falls short of both. Since 2019 Ladakh has been a Union Territory without a legislature, and the absence of elected representation at that level is a genuine grievance.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The Ministry of Home Affairs proposed Article 371(K) at a High Powered Committee sub-committee meeting on 9 September 2026, chaired by Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai. Article 371 sits in Part XXI of the Constitution, and the 371 series already offers special provisions to States such as Nagaland (371A) and Mizoram (371G). Ladakh has two Hill Councils, Leh (1995) and Kargil (2003), under the Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Councils Act, 1997. The Sixth Schedule today covers tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram only. The next round of dialogue was scheduled for 6 October 2026.
Link to governance (L): India’s federalism is asymmetric by design: one template cannot serve every region. The test of any settlement for Ladakh is whether it protects a predominantly tribal, ecologically fragile region and gives its people a say, while keeping the Centre’s role in border security.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Which Part of the Constitution contains Article 371? (Part XXI, “Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions”.)
- How did the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 treat the two Union Territories? (Jammu and Kashmir with a legislature, Ladakh without one.)
- Who represents Ladakh in the talks? (The Leh Apex Body and the Kargil Democratic Alliance.)
Coach Tip: Do not take sides between the Centre and the agitation; show that you understand both the democratic deficit and the border imperative.
International Relations
Q3. Prime Minister Modi and President Xi met on the sidelines of the BRICS Summit in New Delhi in September 2026. Is the India-China thaw durable?
[For: Foreign policy, neighbourhood, strategic patience]
Position (P): The thaw is real but limited. It rests on a shared interest in stability on the border, not on trust, so India should bank its gains while keeping its guard up.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Optimists see a new phase: talks are regular, flights are resuming and both sides want to focus on growth. Sceptics recall that the boundary remains undelimited and that, after Operation Sindoor in 2025, the Army’s deputy chief said Pakistan was the “front face” of a battleground China used as a “live lab”.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The Modi-Xi meeting took place on 12 September 2026 on the sidelines of the 18th BRICS Summit, Xi’s first in-person visit to India since the Mamallapuram informal summit of October 2019. It followed the Eight Points of Outcomes and Consensus issued after the 25th Special Representatives talks in Beijing in August, which invited negotiators to seek an “early and substantial harvest”. China Southern Airlines announced that it would resume Guangzhou-Delhi flights from 21 September 2026. An Indian Express editorial described the two sides as being at a Nash equilibrium on the border, where neither can gain by changing its strategy alone.
Link to governance (L): India’s position is clear: Aksai Chin and Arunachal Pradesh are integral parts of India, and the Line of Actual Control is an effective, not a delimited, boundary. Within that, the 2005 Political Parameters and Guiding Principles allow a step-by-step approach. Diplomacy should seek concrete deliverables in trade and visas while correcting the structural trade imbalance.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What is the package-deal principle? (Nothing is settled until everything is settled.)
- Since when has the Special Representatives mechanism existed? (Since 2003.)
- Should India allow more Chinese investment? (Selectively, in sectors where it builds Indian capacity without creating dependence in critical supply chains.)
Coach Tip: State India’s official position on the boundary calmly and early; then you are free to discuss engagement without seeming naive.
Q4. India is again seeking a permanent seat on the UN Security Council. Is this realistic, and is the UN still worth the effort?
[For: Multilateralism, UN reform, middle-power diplomacy]
Position (P): A permanent seat is a long game, not an immediate prospect. But the UN remains the only forum where every country has a voice, and India gains by shaping it rather than walking away from it.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Reform has stalled for decades. Any Charter amendment needs the support of all five permanent members, some of whom oppose new permanent seats, and groups like Uniting for Consensus resist them altogether.
Illustrate with specifics (I): Under Article 108, a Charter amendment needs two-thirds of the General Assembly and ratification by two-thirds of members including all five permanent members. The Council has been enlarged only once, by a 1963 amendment in force from 1965, from 11 to 15 members. In September 2026 India became a co-sponsor of P4M at its first summit on 21 September, held the first V4+India Foreign Ministers’ Meeting the same day, and is seeking a non-permanent seat for 2028-29, for which Tajikistan is also a candidate. At the General Assembly, Russia’s Foreign Minister backed India and Brazil for permanent seats.
Link to governance (L): India builds support in layers: bilateral endorsements, groupings such as the G4 and P4M, and effective non-permanent terms. India has been elected to the Council eight times, most recently for 2021-22, and each term is a chance to show the responsibility a permanent member needs.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Where do UNSC reform talks take place? (In the General Assembly’s Intergovernmental Negotiations, not in the Security Council.)
- Who are the G4? (India, Brazil, Germany and Japan.)
- What is the Ezulwini Consensus? (Africa’s 2005 position seeking two permanent seats with the veto.)
Coach Tip: Avoid both cynicism and over-confidence; show that you know exactly why reform is hard and what India is doing anyway.
Economy & Development
Q5. In September 2026 the government cut customs duty on crude edible oils. Was this right when India wants farmers to grow more oilseeds?
[For: Agriculture, inflation, trade policy]
Position (P): A temporary duty cut is a reasonable response to food inflation in a weak monsoon year, but it must not become a permanent signal that undercuts the oilseed mission.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Farmers’ groups argue that cheaper imports depress domestic oilseed prices near harvest, and that frequent duty changes make it hard for farmers to plan. They have a point: self-reliance is not built by policies that change every few months.
Illustrate with specifics (I): On 24 September 2026 basic customs duty on crude sunflower oil was cut from 10 per cent to nil, and on crude soybean and palm oil from 10 to 5 per cent; the effective duty differential between crude and refined oils was kept at 19.25 per cent to protect domestic refining. Industry was asked to revise distributor prices and MRPs. India meets about 57 per cent of its edible oil demand through imports, according to the Cabinet in October 2024, while the National Mission on Edible Oils (Oilseeds) targets 69.7 million tonnes of oilseeds by 2030-31.
Link to governance (L): I would favour a rules-based duty band linked to international prices, price-deficiency payments for oilseed farmers, better seeds and diversified import sources, so that relief for consumers and support for farmers are not in conflict every season.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Why keep a gap between crude and refined oil duties? (To encourage refining and value addition in India.)
- Where does India import palm oil from? (Mainly Indonesia and Malaysia.)
- How is NMEO-Oilseeds different from NMEO-OP? (NMEO-OP, 2021, is about oil palm; NMEO-Oilseeds, 2024, covers primary oilseeds such as mustard, groundnut and soybean.)
Coach Tip: Name both the consumer and the farmer in your first answer; the board wants to see that you can hold two legitimate interests at once.
Q6. India’s GDP grew 7.8 per cent in the April to June quarter, but a survey showed factory employment falling. Is India experiencing jobless growth?
[For: Employment, data literacy, economic policy]
Position (P): One month’s survey is not enough to call it jobless growth, but it is a warning worth taking seriously. Growth led by capital goods and investment does not automatically create jobs at the scale India needs.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Several indicators were strong: industrial output rose sharply in August and the quarterly growth figure was robust. Survey indices measure the breadth of change across firms, not its size, so they can dip without a fall in output.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The manufacturing PMI fell to 52.8 in August 2026 from 53.5, the lowest since August 2021, with new orders growing at their slowest in five years and factory employment falling for the first time in about two and a half years. The Index of Industrial Production, on its new 2022-23 base, rose 8.0 per cent in August, with capital goods up 16.9 per cent but consumer non-durables up only 2.1 per cent. A high year-on-year rate can also reflect a low base.
Link to governance (L): Policy should support labour-intensive sectors such as textiles, food processing and construction, strengthen rural demand, and improve high-frequency employment data so that warnings are spotted early.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What does a PMI above 50 mean? (More firms report expansion than contraction.)
- What is a base effect? (A growth rate that looks high or low because of an unusually low or high figure in the comparison period.)
- What is K-shaped growth? (Some sectors and income groups recover strongly while others stagnate.)
Coach Tip: Show data literacy: distinguish breadth from size and year-on-year from month-on-month, and you will stand out from candidates who simply say “jobless growth” or “all is well”.
Security & Defence
Q7. AFSPA was extended in parts of Manipur, Nagaland and Arunachal Pradesh from October 2026. Should it be repealed?
[For: Internal security, human rights, the North-East]
Position (P): AFSPA should be time-bound and shrinking, not permanent. Where violence has ended it should be withdrawn; where it continues, it should come with transparent accountability and a plan to hand responsibility back to the police.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Security forces operating against armed groups need legal protection for actions taken in good faith. Equally, many in the North-East see the Act as a symbol of distrust, and allegations of abuse have damaged faith in the state.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The declarations take effect from 1 October 2026 for six months under Section 3 of the 1958 Act. They cover Manipur except 13 police stations in five valley districts; nine districts plus 21 police station areas in five districts of Nagaland; and Tirap, Changlang and Longding plus three police stations in Namsai in Arunachal Pradesh. Section 6 bars prosecution without the prior sanction of the Central Government. The Supreme Court upheld the Act in Naga People’s Movement of Human Rights (1997) but in EEVFAM (2016) denied absolute immunity.
Link to governance (L): The Jeevan Reddy Committee and the Second Administrative Reforms Commission both examined the Act. The lasting answer is a capable State police, so that the Army is used in aid of civil power only briefly, and transparent decisions on sanction for prosecution.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Who can declare an area “disturbed”? (Both the Governor and the Central Government; the Centre’s power was added in 1972.)
- Does the 1958 Act apply to Jammu and Kashmir? (No; J&K has a separate 1990 Act.)
- How does the Union deploy forces when public order is a State subject? (Under Entry 2A of List I, added by the 42nd Amendment.)
Coach Tip: Avoid slogans for or against; the board values candidates who can speak for both the soldier and the citizen.
Science & Technology
Q8. India has opened nuclear power to private players under the SHANTI framework. Is this a wise move?
[For: Energy security, nuclear policy, regulation]
Position (P): Private entry is necessary if India is to scale nuclear power, but it is wise only if the regulator is strong and independent and if accident liability protects the public.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Critics worry about safety culture in profit-driven operators and about the removal of the statutory right of recourse against suppliers, which India’s 2010 liability law had provided as a departure from the international practice of channelling liability to the operator.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The SHANTI Act came into effect on 21 December 2025, replacing the Atomic Energy Act, 1962 and the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010. Draft Rules and Regulations were published on 14 August 2026, and public consultation closed on 4 September 2026. Under the framework, recourse against a supplier is contractual only, with a carve-out for intentional acts; the draft Rules would require operators to hold insurance or equivalent financial security and would provide a single composite licence from construction to decommissioning. India has 24 operational reactors with about 8,780 MW, against a Nuclear Energy Mission target of 100 GW by 2047.
Link to governance (L): The arithmetic of moving from under 9 GW to 100 GW is what forced private entry. The safeguards that matter are a statutory, independent Atomic Energy Regulatory Board, adequate insurance pools and transparent public consultation near plant sites.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What fuels stage two of India’s three-stage programme? (Plutonium in fast breeder reactors; thorium belongs to stage three.)
- What milestone did the Kalpakkam PFBR reach in 2026? (First criticality on 6 April 2026.)
- What is operator liability channelling? (International practice of placing liability for nuclear damage on the operator, not the supplier.)
Coach Tip: Treat it as three reforms in one: market opening, liability and regulatory independence; answering each separately shows clarity.
Environment & Geography
Q9. A UNEP report in September 2026 treats exceeding 1.5 degrees Celsius as unavoidable. Is the 1.5 degree target dead, and should we keep talking about it?
[For: Climate change, global negotiations, India’s position]
Position (P): Exceeding 1.5 degrees may now be unavoidable, but the target still matters, because how high and how long temperatures overshoot decides how much irreversible damage is done.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Some argue that clinging to a target that will be missed damages credibility, and that an “overshoot” framing could even become an excuse to delay cuts.
Illustrate with specifics (I): UNEP’s Spotlight Report Limiting Overshoot, released on 2 September 2026, finds a best case in which warming peaks at about 1.8 degrees around midcentury, while current policies point to a median of about 2.6 degrees by 2100. Returning to 1.5 degrees with limited exceedance requires emissions 55 per cent below 2019 levels by 2035. Temperature may come down, but ice-sheet loss, sea-level rise and extinction do not run backwards.
Link to governance (L): For India, the case rests on historical responsibility and per capita emissions below the global average, alongside real domestic action such as tighter vehicle fuel-efficiency norms and grid investment for renewables. Overshoot also moves adaptation and loss-and-damage finance to the centre of negotiations, which matters for vulnerable countries.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What does the Paris Agreement actually require? (Holding warming well below 2 degrees while pursuing efforts to limit it to 1.5 degrees.)
- Is UNEP the same as the IPCC? (No; UNEP is a UN programme headquartered at Nairobi, and the IPCC is a separate scientific body.)
- When is India’s net zero target? (2070.)
Coach Tip: Use the idea of peak temperature to show that “1.5 is lost” and “1.5 still matters” are not contradictory.
Q10. Gujarat has only three wild Great Indian Bustards, all female. Is it worth spending heavily to save the species there?
[For: Biodiversity, grasslands, development and conservation]
Position (P): Yes. The Great Indian Bustard is a flagship for India’s neglected grasslands, and saving it protects a whole ecosystem, not just a bird.
Acknowledge the other side (A): With so few birds left in Gujarat, some argue that resources would do more good elsewhere, and that habitat protection can clash with renewable energy lines and local land use.
Illustrate with specifics (I): The Gujarat Action Plan for the Conservation of the Great Indian Bustard was released at Bhuj on 13 September 2026 by Union Minister Bhupender Yadav, prepared by the Wildlife Institute of India with the Gujarat Forest Department. It targets a minimum viable population of 30-plus birds in Kachchh, a target rather than a current count, and aims to secure 200 to 500 sq km of habitat, starting with about 200 sq km in the Lala-Rawa landscape. It provides for egg-swapping from Rajasthan’s conservation breeding programme and a soft release centre near Naliya; a chick hatched from a swapped egg on 26 March 2026. The species is Critically Endangered and in Schedule I of the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972.
Link to governance (L): Grasslands remain an under-recognised biome in conservation planning. A landscape approach that works with herders, removes invasive Prosopis juliflora and routes power lines safely can reconcile clean energy with conservation.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What is a minimum viable population? (The smallest population with a high probability of persisting in the wild over a given period, allowing for genetic and demographic risk.)
- Where are the GIB’s strongholds? (Desert National Park, Jaisalmer, and Kachchh.)
- How many cheetahs did Project Cheetah report at its 13 September 2026 review? (52, across Kuno and Gandhi Sagar in Madhya Pradesh; by 22 September the count stood at 55, after four cubs were born and the cheetah Gaurav died.)
Coach Tip: Frame the bird as an indicator of grassland health; that turns a “why spend money” question into a question about ecosystems and livelihoods.
Social Issues
Q11. India’s HPV vaccination campaign crossed 80 lakh doses in September 2026. Is vaccination enough to eliminate cervical cancer?
[For: Public health, women’s health, health systems]
Position (P): Vaccination is the most powerful tool, but not enough on its own. Elimination needs screening and treatment for women already beyond the vaccine age.
Acknowledge the other side (A): The campaign’s speed is impressive and a single dose makes coverage far easier. Yet vaccine hesitancy, the need for parental consent and gaps in hard-to-reach areas mean coverage will not be uniform without sustained effort.
Illustrate with specifics (I): India crossed 80 lakh HPV vaccinations by 11 September 2026 under the National HPV Vaccination Campaign launched in February 2026. It offers a voluntary, free, single dose to 14-year-old girls with parental consent, using the quadrivalent Gardasil-4 procured through Gavi. Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Mizoram have crossed their identified targets. The WHO’s 90-70-90 targets for 2030 call for 90 per cent vaccination, 70 per cent screening and 90 per cent treatment, and “elimination” means fewer than 4 cases per 100,000 women a year, not zero.
Link to governance (L): Cervical cancer is the second most common cancer among Indian women. School-based delivery, trusted health workers, screening at primary health centres and a strong indigenous vaccine base can together turn a campaign into lasting protection.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- Why a single dose? (The WHO’s SAGE recommended a single-dose schedule in 2022.)
- Is Cervavac the campaign vaccine? (No; it is an indigenous quadrivalent vaccine by the Serum Institute of India, authorised in July 2022, but the campaign uses Gardasil-4.)
- Should boys be vaccinated too? (HPV also causes cancers in males; the campaign is female-only for cost-effectiveness, and extending it is a question of budget and evidence.)
Coach Tip: Distinguish elimination from eradication; it shows precision and avoids overstating what the campaign can do.
Ethics & Governance
Q12. Tamil Nadu notified its law and order department as an “intelligence and security organisation” outside the RTI Act, then withdrew the order within hours. What does the episode tell us about transparency in policing?
[For: Transparency, accountability, administrative ethics]
Position (P): Sensitive operational information deserves protection, but exempting an entire police department from the RTI Act is the wrong tool. The quick withdrawal shows that public scrutiny can correct such decisions.
Acknowledge the other side (A): Police work involves intelligence, informants and operations that could be endangered by disclosure, and States have a legal power to exempt their own intelligence and security organisations.
Illustrate with specifics (I): G.O. Ms. No. 57, dated 21 September 2026, had specified the Public (Law and Order) Department as an “intelligence and security organisation” under Section 24(4) of the RTI Act, 2005. The Tamil Nadu government revoked it on 27 September 2026, within hours of it becoming public, after criticism from transparency groups and parties supporting the government. Even exempt bodies must disclose information on corruption, and, with the Information Commission’s approval, on human rights violations, under the proviso to Section 24. On 15 June 2026, in Special Police Establishment v. Kamta Prasad Mishra, the Supreme Court applied a functional test and held that the Madhya Pradesh Lokayukta’s Special Police Establishment is not an intelligence and security organisation.
Link to governance (L): The right to information flows from Article 19(1)(a). Section 8 already protects categories of sensitive information; an organisation-wide exemption hides accountability records along with genuine secrets. As an officer, I would protect what is sensitive item by item and keep everything else open.
Follow-up questions you should be ready for:
- What is the difference between Section 24 and Section 8? (Section 24 exempts organisations; Section 8 exempts categories of information.)
- Can a State exempt a central agency? (No; only organisations it has established.)
- When is the International Day for Universal Access to Information? (28 September.)
Coach Tip: Praise the course correction without scoring political points; the board looks for candidates who value transparency as a principle, not as a weapon.