GS Paper 1: History, Geography & Society
Q1. Maharashtra’s 2026 law recognises women engaged in farming as farmers regardless of land ownership. Discuss the feminisation of Indian agriculture and examine whether such recognition can translate into empowerment.
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: Women do an estimated 65 to 75 per cent of farm work in India but own under 14 per cent of agricultural land. The Maharashtra Women Farmers Empowerment Act, 2026 is the first State law to recognise them as farmers through a Woman Farmer Certificate, decoupling farmer status from land title.
Feminisation of Agriculture: Causes
- Male out-migration to cities for non-farm work leaves women to manage farms.
- Distress and low returns push men out first, so women’s share rises in a shrinking, precarious sector.
- Patriarchal land inheritance, despite the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, keeps titles with men.
Why Recognition Matters
- Most schemes (crop insurance, credit, PM-KISAN, procurement) key off the land record, so the landless woman farmer is invisible.
- A certificate opens institutional credit, insurance and market access; a dedicated State fund backs it.
- It gives statistical visibility, which is the first step to policy attention.
Limits: Recognition Is Not Yet Empowerment
- Without ownership, women still lack collateral and decision-making power over what to grow and sell.
- Feminisation often reflects distress, not choice; recognition may formalise a burden.
- Implementation depends on village-level verification, where local power structures can exclude women.
Way Forward
- Pair recognition with joint or individual titles (land-record digitisation, joint pattas).
- Route extension services, FPO membership and machinery banks to women farmers.
- Link to SHG networks under DAY-NRLM and to Lakhpati Didi targets.
- Build gender-disaggregated agricultural data into the Agriculture Census.
Conclusion: Recognition corrects an injustice of invisibility; empowerment needs assets, voice and markets. Maharashtra’s law is a necessary first step that others should follow and deepen.
Key concepts: feminisation of agriculture; land rights; Article 15(3); Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005; FPOs; SHGs.
Q2. June 2026 closed about 40 per cent below normal rainfall even as a strong El Nino was forecast. Explain how El Nino, the Indian Ocean Dipole and the Madden-Julian Oscillation shape the Indian monsoon, and outline the economic consequences of a weak season.
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: The southwest monsoon brings about 75 per cent of India’s annual rainfall. In 2026, June ended about 40 per cent below normal, and the WMO’s late-July update forecast a strong El Nino, raising the risk of a weak season.
The Drivers
- El Nino (ENSO warm phase): Warm waters in the central and eastern Pacific shift the rising limb of the Walker circulation eastward, weakening convection over India.
- Indian Ocean Dipole: A positive IOD (warmer western Indian Ocean) favours the monsoon and can offset El Nino, as in 1997 and 2019.
- Madden-Julian Oscillation: An eastward-moving pulse of cloud and rain (30 to 60 days) that switches the monsoon between active and break phases within a season.
- Local factors: Monsoon trough position, low-pressure systems from the Bay of Bengal, and Eurasian snow cover.
Economic Consequences
- Agriculture: Kharif sowing of paddy, pulses and oilseeds depends on June-July rain; rainfed areas (about half the net sown area) suffer most.
- Inflation: Food prices rise; CPI inflation had already crossed 4 per cent in June 2026.
- Power: Lower hydropower and higher cooling demand widen the gap filled by coal; CREA estimated an 18 TWh gap in the El Nino year.
- Water and rural demand: Reservoir stress, and weaker rural consumption.
Way Forward
- Contingency crop plans and advisories through district agromet units.
- Expand micro-irrigation (Per Drop More Crop) and watershed works.
- Buffer stocks and open-market sales to cap food inflation.
- Invest in seasonal forecasting at district scale.
Conclusion: A weak monsoon is no longer a single shock but a test of adaptive capacity across farms, prices and power grids.
Key concepts: ENSO; Walker circulation; IOD; MJO; rainfed agriculture; food inflation.
Q3. The inscription of Sarnath as India’s 45th World Heritage property in July 2026 highlights the place of Buddhist heritage in India’s culture and diplomacy. Discuss.
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On July 25, 2026 the World Heritage Committee, meeting in Busan, inscribed the Ancient Buddhist Site of Sarnath, where the Buddha delivered his first sermon, as India’s 45th World Heritage property and Uttar Pradesh’s fourth.
Sarnath in Indian Culture
- Religious significance: The first sermon set the Wheel of Dharma in motion; with Lumbini, Bodh Gaya and Kushinagar, it is one of the four great pilgrimage sites.
- Art and architecture: The Dhamek and Dharmarajika stupas, the Chaukhandi Stupa, and the Sarnath school of Gupta sculpture, known for its fine, transparent drapery.
- National symbolism: The Ashokan Lion Capital found here is India’s State Emblem; the Dharma Chakra is on the National Flag.
Buddhist Heritage in Diplomacy
- Soft power in Asia: Shared Buddhist heritage links India with Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand, Japan, Mongolia and Vietnam; relic expositions abroad draw large crowds.
- Act East and connectivity: The Buddhist Circuit under Swadesh Darshan and the International Buddhist Confederation support tourism and people-to-people ties.
- Counter-narrative: It presents India as the source of a pan-Asian civilisational tradition.
Challenges
- Balancing pilgrimage and tourism with conservation under the AMASR Act, 1958 (100 m prohibited and 200 m regulated zones).
- Urban pressure around Varanasi; managing a buffer zone.
- Ensuring local communities benefit.
Way Forward
- A site management plan with community participation.
- Link Sarnath to an integrated Buddhist circuit with Bodh Gaya, Kushinagar, Nalanda and Sanchi.
- Use the inscription to deepen academic exchange, such as Nalanda University.
Conclusion: Sarnath’s inscription recognises its Outstanding Universal Value and gives India a platform for heritage-led diplomacy, provided conservation keeps pace with visibility.
Key concepts: Outstanding Universal Value; Sarnath school; Buddhist circuit; AMASR Act; soft power.
GS Paper 2: Polity, Governance & International Relations
Q4. The NEET-UG 2026 leak led to the resignation of the Union Education Minister, a task force on the National Testing Agency and a tougher public examinations law. Examine the institutional reforms needed to restore trust in India’s public examinations.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: NEET-UG 2026 was held on May 3, cancelled after a leak and re-held on June 21 for more than 20 lakh candidates. In July the Education Minister resigned, a six-member task force under Nandan Nilekani was set up on the NTA, and Parliament passed an amendment raising the punishment for organised leaks to a minimum of 7 years and a fine of at least Rs 10 crore.
Why Trust Broke Down
- Centralised, high-stakes design: A single pen-and-paper exam for over 20 lakh candidates creates one point of failure.
- Weak institutional form: The NTA is a society, not a statutory body, with limited accountability to Parliament.
- Long supply chain: Printing, transport and centre management involve many private vendors.
- Repeat failures: The Radhakrishnan Committee (2024) had already made 101 recommendations.
Institutional Reforms
- Statutory footing for the NTA, with a clear mandate, audit and parliamentary oversight.
- Computer-based testing with randomised question sets drawn from a secure item bank, as planned from 2027.
- Technology for integrity: encrypted digital delivery, AI-based anomaly detection and blockchain-based verification, as the task force’s brief suggests.
- Vendor accountability: Debarment and heavy penalties for service providers (up to Rs 5 crore under the amendment).
- Decentralisation debate: Allow State-level options while keeping common standards, respecting Entry 25 of the Concurrent List.
- Speedy justice: Special fast-track courts and time-bound investigation.
Beyond Punishment Stiffer penalties deter, but reliability comes from design and institutions. A grievance and transparency system (answer-key challenges, public audit) rebuilds candidate confidence.
Conclusion: A minister’s resignation settles political accountability; restoring trust needs a statutory, technologically secure and transparent examination system.
Key concepts: NTA; Public Examinations Act, 2024; Radhakrishnan Committee; computer-based testing; institutional accountability.
Q5. “Deletion from the electoral roll is not loss of citizenship.” In the light of the Supreme Court’s July 2026 observation, examine the limits of the Election Commission’s role in verifying citizenship during a Special Intensive Revision of rolls.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On July 17, 2026 a Supreme Court bench led by the Chief Justice, hearing challenges to the Special Intensive Revision of rolls in West Bengal, held that deletion from the roll does not amount to loss of citizenship; the ECI may assess citizenship only for preparing rolls.
Constitutional and Legal Framework
- Article 324: Superintendence of elections, including electoral rolls, vests in the ECI.
- Article 326: Adult suffrage for citizens aged 18 and above.
- Representation of the People Act, 1950: Registration requires citizenship, age and ordinary residence.
- Citizenship Act, 1955: Acquisition and termination of citizenship are matters for the Union; Foreigners Tribunals decide disputed nationality.
Why the Distinction Matters
- Separation of functions: The ECI registers eligible voters; it is not a citizenship-determining authority.
- Due process: A person struck off for missing documents is not thereby a foreigner; Article 21 requires a fair procedure before any finding on nationality.
- Burden of proof: Mass verification can shift the burden onto the poor, migrants and women without documents.
Concerns in SIR Exercises
- Risk of large-scale exclusion of eligible voters.
- Tight timelines and document demands.
- Uneven capacity of booth-level officers.
Safeguards
- Notice, hearing and reasoned orders before deletion.
- Accept a wide range of documents and field verification.
- Transparent publication of draft rolls and deletions with appeal routes.
- Separate any citizenship inquiry, which must follow the Citizenship Act and the Foreigners Act.
Conclusion: A clean roll is essential, but the right to vote rests on citizenship, which only due legal process can take away. Keeping roll revision and citizenship determination distinct protects both electoral integrity and individual rights.
Key concepts: Article 324; Article 326; RP Act, 1950; Citizenship Act, 1955; due process; SIR.
Q6. The Joint Parliamentary Committee on the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024 has said simultaneous elections “conform to the Constitution”. Critically examine the implications of One Nation, One Election for Indian federalism.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: The 129th Amendment Bill proposes a new Article 82A and amendments to Articles 83, 172 and 327 to synchronise Lok Sabha and Assembly elections. The JPC, chaired by P.P. Chaudhary, received an extension on July 29, 2026 to the last week of the Winter Session.
Arguments For
- Cost and governance: Fewer elections reduce expenditure and the policy paralysis of repeated Model Codes of Conduct.
- Historical precedent: Elections were simultaneous in 1951-52, 1957, 1962 and 1967.
- Voter fatigue: A single cycle may raise turnout.
Federal Concerns
- Curtailed Assembly terms: Assemblies elected mid-cycle would serve truncated terms, touching the autonomy implied by Article 172.
- National issues dominating State polls: Regional parties fear being overshadowed.
- Premature dissolution: A fresh election only for the remainder of the term may encourage instability or reduce accountability.
- Ratification: Extending synchronisation to local bodies would need ratification by half the States (Article 368(2) proviso).
- Basic structure: Federalism and democracy are basic features (S.R. Bommai, 1994; Kesavananda Bharati, 1973).
Design Questions
- How no-confidence motions and the Tenth Schedule interact with fixed cycles.
- The ECI’s logistical capacity (EVMs, VVPATs, personnel).
Way Forward
- Broad consensus with States and parties.
- A constructive vote of no-confidence to limit mid-term collapses.
- Phased alignment, beginning where terms naturally converge.
Conclusion: Simultaneous elections can improve governance, but only if designed to preserve the federal balance and democratic accountability that the Constitution protects.
Key concepts: Article 82A; Article 172; Kovind Committee; basic structure; federalism; Tenth Schedule.
Q7. Defence exports have become an instrument of India’s Act East policy. Examine this with reference to India’s partnerships in Southeast Asia and the Indo-Pacific in 2026.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In July 2026 India agreed to supply BrahMos missiles to Indonesia, which also placed the first export order for the Astra Mk1 air-to-air missile. With earlier BrahMos deals with the Philippines and Vietnam, defence exports now anchor India’s ties with Southeast Asia.
Why Defence Exports Serve Act East
- Capability for partners: Coastal states facing pressure in the South China Sea gain anti-ship and air-defence capability.
- Strategic trust: Arms relationships create long-term ties through training, maintenance and upgrades.
- Atmanirbharta: Exports give scale to Indian industry (BrahMos Aerospace, BDL) and fund research.
- Balance of power: A network of capable partners supports a free, open and inclusive Indo-Pacific.
The Wider July 2026 Picture
- Japan: A Joint Declaration on Economic Security and the first defence co-development project, the UNICORN stealth mast.
- Australia: Uranium supply under the civil nuclear agreement, and defence and critical-minerals outcomes.
- New Zealand: Ties raised to a Strategic Partnership.
- Multilateral: Support for a legally binding South China Sea Code of Conduct consistent with UNCLOS.
Challenges
- Financing: partners need lines of credit.
- Competition from established suppliers.
- Export controls and after-sales support.
- Managing China’s reactions while keeping strategic autonomy.
Way Forward
- Defence lines of credit and joint production in partner countries.
- A dedicated export promotion agency and faster clearances.
- Combine hard power with economic ties (supply chains, connectivity, digital public infrastructure).
Conclusion: From “Look East” to “Act East”, India is adding a security dimension; defence exports, if backed by finance and reliability, make India a credible partner rather than a distant well-wisher.
Key concepts: Act East; net security provider; BrahMos; Astra; UNCLOS; strategic autonomy.
GS Paper 3: Economy, Environment, Science & Security
Q8. Semicon 2.0 (Rs 1,27,500 crore) and the Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme (Rs 62,500 crore) aim to move India from assembly to value addition. Critically examine India’s electronics and semiconductor strategy.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On July 15, 2026 the Cabinet approved the second phase of the India Semiconductor Mission and a successor to the phone PLI focused on components and sub-assemblies. Earlier in the month, a Rs 7,600 crore assembly-and-test (OSAT) plant opened at Sanand.
Progress So Far
- India is the world’s second-largest mobile phone maker.
- ISM 1.0 attracted OSAT and assembly units (Micron, CG Semi, Kaynes) and the first fab projects.
- A growing design base: chip-design start-ups and talent programmes.
Why Start With Assembly and Testing
- Lower capital and technology barriers than a fab.
- Builds skills, suppliers and ecosystem.
- Captures “China plus one” diversification.
Concerns
- Low domestic value addition: Phones are largely assembled from imported components, many from China.
- Fab economics: Fabs cost billions, need uninterrupted power, ultra-pure water and specialty gases.
- Input dependence: Helium, rare earths and chemicals are imported; China’s July 2026 helium export ban showed the risk.
- Subsidy dependence: Incentives must lead to competitive firms, not permanent support.
Way Forward
- Link incentives to domestic value addition, not just output.
- Develop component clusters (displays, batteries, PCBs).
- Secure critical inputs through critical-mineral auctions and partnerships (India-Japan economic security, ACITI).
- Invest in design, R&D and talent; integrate with trusted partners.
Conclusion: India has moved from “assemble in India” towards “make in India”; Semicon 2.0 and MPMS will succeed if they build competitiveness in the value chain rather than scale alone.
Key concepts: OSAT; fab; domestic value addition; PLI; supply-chain resilience; China plus one.
Q9. With the four Labour Codes in force, a new EPF Scheme, 2026 and social-protection coverage said to cross one billion people, examine how far India has moved towards universal social security for its informal workforce.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In July 2026 the four Labour Codes moved into active enforcement, the EPF Scheme, 2026 replaced the 1952 scheme under the Code on Social Security, 2020, and India said its social-protection coverage had crossed one billion people (about 68.4 per cent), a figure the ILO acknowledged.
Progress
- Consolidation: 29 central laws merged into four codes; the Social Security Code recognises gig and platform workers.
- Wage definition: The 50 per cent wage rule widens the base for provident fund and gratuity.
- Digital delivery: EPFO’s single national system (about 34 crore accounts), e-Shram registration, and Aadhaar-linked transfers.
- Welfare expansion: Food security, health insurance (Ayushman Bharat) and pensions widen the safety net.
Gaps
- Coverage vs adequacy: Counting food rations or health cover as social protection overstates income security in old age or unemployment.
- Informal workforce: Most workers remain outside contributory pensions and unemployment insurance.
- Gig workers: Contributions from aggregators and portability need implementation.
- Federal delivery: Labour is in the Concurrent List; State rules vary.
Way Forward
- A universal social-security account portable across jobs and States.
- Rules and funding for the gig-worker social security fund.
- Minimum floors for pensions and maternity benefits for informal workers.
- Regular, transparent data on coverage and benefit adequacy.
Conclusion: India has built the legal and digital scaffolding for universal social security; making it meaningful for informal workers needs adequate benefits, portability and funding.
Key concepts: Code on Social Security, 2020; EPF Scheme, 2026; gig workers; e-Shram; ILO; social-protection floor.
Q10. Repeated disruption in the Strait of Hormuz in 2026 exposed India’s energy vulnerability. Examine the measures India should take to strengthen its energy security.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: The US-Iran war, begun in February 2026, choked the Strait of Hormuz again in late July after strikes near Bandar Abbas and Kish. A large share of India’s crude and LNG imports passes through the Strait.
Dimensions of Vulnerability
- Import dependence: India imports most of its crude oil and about half of its natural gas.
- Chokepoint concentration: Gulf supplies depend on Hormuz; freight and insurance costs spike in crises.
- Thin buffers: Strategic petroleum reserves at Visakhapatnam, Mangaluru and Padur cover only days of consumption.
- Macro impact: Oil shocks widen the current account deficit and push inflation.
Measures
- Diversify sources and routes: Russia, the US, West Africa and Latin America; long-term contracts.
- Deepen reserves: Expand SPR capacity, including with private and foreign partners.
- Demand-side transition: Electric mobility, E20 ethanol blending, energy efficiency (CAFE norms).
- Domestic supply: Exploration, coal gasification, compressed biogas and green hydrogen.
- Markets: Domestic price benchmarks (NSE natural gas futures) and gas exchanges improve price discovery.
- Diplomacy and security: Naval presence for freedom of navigation; partnerships in the Gulf.
Balancing Acts
- Affordability versus diversification costs.
- Climate commitments (net zero by 2070) versus near-term fossil needs.
Way Forward A national energy-security framework combining reserves, diversification, transition fuels and maritime security.
Conclusion: Energy security is now both an economic and a strategic question; buffers and diversification buy time, and the energy transition is the long-term hedge.
Key concepts: chokepoint; strategic petroleum reserve; energy transition; E20; green hydrogen; freedom of navigation.
Q11. The seventh draft notification on the Western Ghats Eco-Sensitive Area and the Supreme Court’s rejection of ex-post-facto environmental clearances point to recurring weaknesses in environmental governance. Discuss.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On July 27, 2026 MoEFCC issued its seventh draft notification proposing 56,825.7 sq km across six States as the Western Ghats ESA. In July the Supreme Court also quashed a 2021 Office Memorandum that allowed indefinite retrospective clearances.
The Western Ghats Deadlock
- The Gadgil panel (2011) treated the whole range as ecologically sensitive; the Kasturirangan panel (2013) proposed about 37 per cent.
- Six earlier drafts lapsed amid State objections over livelihoods and development.
- Disasters such as the 2024 Wayanad landslide show the cost of delay.
Ex-Post-Facto Clearances
- The EIA Notification, 2006 requires prior environmental clearance.
- Retrospective approvals reward violators and make appraisal a formality.
- The Court held that only a statutory notification, not an administrative memorandum, can create exceptions, invoking the precautionary and polluter-pays principles.
Common Weaknesses
- Centre-State friction and the absence of a consensus-building mechanism.
- Weak appraisal and monitoring capacity.
- Treating environmental law as a hurdle rather than a safeguard.
- Limited participation of local communities and gram sabhas.
Way Forward
- Finalise the ESA with village-level ground truthing and livelihood support.
- A statutory, independent environmental regulator, as the Supreme Court has suggested before.
- Strengthen post-clearance monitoring and public disclosure.
- Use cumulative impact assessment for ecologically fragile regions.
Conclusion: Environmental governance fails less for lack of laws than for lack of timely, credible enforcement; the Western Ghats and the clearance ruling both call for rules that are made on time and applied without exceptions.
Key concepts: Eco-Sensitive Area; EIA Notification, 2006; Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; precautionary principle; polluter pays.
Q12. The deaths of 25 workers in the tunnel of the Teesta Stage-VI project in July 2026 have renewed scrutiny of hydropower construction in the Himalaya. Examine the risks and suggest a framework for safer development.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On July 20, 2026 a suspected methane burst in the head race tunnel of NHPC’s 500 MW Teesta Stage-VI project in Sikkim killed all 25 workers trapped inside. It followed earlier disasters in the region, including the 2023 Teesta-III glacial lake outburst flood.
Risks of Himalayan Hydropower
- Geology: Young, fractured, seismically active mountains; tunnelling through faults can release gas and water.
- Climate change: Glacial lake outburst floods, cloudbursts and landslides are becoming more frequent.
- Cumulative impact: Cascades of projects on one river alter flows and slopes.
- Worker safety: Gas monitoring, ventilation and escape routes are often inadequate.
Why Hydropower Still Matters
- Clean, dispatchable power that balances solar and wind.
- Water storage and flood moderation.
- Strategic value in border regions.
Framework for Safer Development
- Before construction: Detailed geological mapping, cumulative basin studies and seismic design.
- During construction: Mandatory gas detection, ventilation, rescue chambers and trained response teams.
- Early warning: GLOF monitoring and automatic warning systems.
- Regulation: Independent safety audits, and publication of findings after accidents.
- Community: Consultation with local communities and fair compensation.
Disaster Management Link The NDMA’s guidelines on GLOFs and the Disaster Management Act, 2005 should cover construction-phase hazards.
Conclusion: The question is not whether to build in the Himalaya but how; science-based siting, strict safety standards and transparency must come before speed.
Key concepts: GLOF; cumulative impact assessment; tunnel safety; Disaster Management Act, 2005; run-of-the-river projects.
GS Paper 4: Ethics, Integrity & Aptitude (Case Studies)
Q13. You are the head of an examination body. Hours before a national entrance test, you receive credible information that the question paper may have leaked on social media. Cancelling will disrupt lakhs of candidates; proceeding may reward cheating.
(a) Identify the ethical issues involved. (b) What course of action would you take, and why?
[GS-4 | 20 Marks | 250 Words]
Context: In 2026 the NEET-UG leak led to a cancelled examination, a re-test for more than 20 lakh candidates and a minister’s resignation. Decisions in the first hours after a suspected leak shape public trust.
(a) Ethical Issues
- Fairness and equal opportunity: Honest candidates must not compete against those with leaked papers (Article 14 spirit).
- Transparency vs panic: Disclosing unverified information can cause chaos; hiding it erodes trust.
- Accountability: The head of the body answers for systems, not only for individual culprits.
- Proportionality: The cost of cancellation to candidates and families versus the cost of a compromised result.
- Integrity of institutions: Long-term credibility outweighs short-term convenience.
(b) Course of Action
- Verify quickly: Match the circulated paper with the sealed set through a small, trusted team; alert cyber police.
- Use contingency design: Switch to a reserve paper set if available; delay rather than cancel if the switch is feasible.
- If the leak is confirmed and no secure set exists: Postpone, announce clearly and early, and fix a new date.
- Communicate honestly: A public statement with facts, next steps and helplines.
- Protect candidates: Refund fees, arrange travel support, and ensure the re-test is fair.
- Fix responsibility: FIR under the Public Examinations Act, internal inquiry, and vendor audit.
- Offer accountability: If systems under my charge failed, accept responsibility and cooperate fully with inquiries.
Ethical Anchor: Fairness to the honest candidate is the core duty; transparency and accountability, not concealment, protect the institution in the long run.
Key concepts: fairness; transparency; accountability; role morality; public trust; proportionality.
Q14. As District Collector, you face a protest by tribal families displaced by a river-linking project in your district. They say promised land, compensation and rehabilitation have not been delivered and threaten to continue an indefinite agitation. The State government wants the project to proceed on schedule.
(a) Identify the stakeholders and the values in conflict. (b) How would you resolve the situation?
[GS-4 | 20 Marks | 250 Words]
Context: In July 2026 displaced tribal families revived the “Chita Andolan”, a pyre protest, against the Ken-Betwa Link Project in Madhya Pradesh, saying rehabilitation promises had not been kept.
(a) Stakeholders and Values
- Stakeholders: Displaced families, especially women and tribal communities; the State government; project agencies; downstream beneficiaries in drought-prone Bundelkhand; civil society.
- Values in conflict: Development and water security versus rights and dignity; rule of law versus compassion; speed versus due process; the greater good versus justice to the few who bear the cost.
(b) Resolution
- Engage immediately: Meet the protesters in person; ensure their safety and prevent any harm during the protest.
- Establish facts: Audit entitlements under the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and the Forest Rights Act, 2006; publish a status list of each family’s compensation and land allotment.
- Deliver what is due: Time-bound disbursement of pending compensation; land-for-land where promised; fix responsibility for delays.
- Consult: Gram sabha meetings; a grievance cell with community representatives, including women.
- Advise the government honestly: Explain that proceeding without rehabilitation risks unrest, litigation and legitimacy; recommend linking project milestones to rehabilitation milestones.
- Livelihoods: Skill training, employment on the project, and support for new settlements (schools, health, water).
Ethical Anchor: A public servant must make development inclusive; the people who give up their land for the public good deserve priority, not an afterthought.
Key concepts: RFCTLARR Act, 2013; Forest Rights Act, 2006; distributive justice; empathy; participatory governance.
Essay
Q15. “Institutions, not individuals, are the guarantors of public trust.”
[Essay | 125 Marks | 1000-1200 Words]
Suggested outline for an essay grounded in July 2026 developments:
Hook and Thesis: Open with July 2026: a leaked examination, a minister’s resignation, and a task force asked to redesign the testing system. The resignation satisfied a demand for accountability, but candidates’ trust depends on whether the next examination is secure. Thesis: individuals can symbolise accountability, but only institutions can sustain trust.
Conceptual Frame:
- Trust as a public good that lowers the cost of governance.
- Institutions as rules, norms and organisations that outlast individuals.
- Individual virtue matters, but systems must not depend on it.
Illustrations:
(a) Examinations and education: The NTA as a society without statutory backing; the need for a statutory, technology-secured, transparent body.
(b) Judiciary: Raising the Supreme Court’s strength helps only with procedural reform, court management and filled vacancies.
(c) Elections: The Supreme Court’s distinction between roll deletion and citizenship shows how institutional limits protect rights.
(d) Economy: The RBI’s inflation-targeting framework and the GST Council show how rule-based institutions anchor expectations.
(e) Environment: Repeated draft notifications for the Western Ghats show the cost of weak institutions: decisions postponed until disaster.
Historical Anchoring:
- The Constituent Assembly’s design of independent institutions (ECI, CAG, UPSC).
- Episodes where institutions held under pressure, and where they bent.
Counter-arguments:
- Individuals build and reform institutions: T.N. Seshan and the ECI, E. Sreedharan and the Metro.
- Leadership sets culture; institutions without ethical leaders can be captured.
Synthesis: Trust is institutional in structure and individual in spirit: good institutions make honest behaviour the default and dishonest behaviour costly, while good leaders strengthen institutions rather than replace them.
Conclusion: Return to the aspirant waiting for a re-test. What restores faith is not the resignation but a paper that cannot leak and a system that answers for failure. Build institutions worthy of trust, and let individuals be measured by how well they serve them.