The Lift Line
“A blanket presumption of kidnapping or trafficking in every case of a missing adult, without any evidence, is against the spirit of the statute.”
Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam
R.K. Vij, a former IPS officer, writes from the police station’s point of view about a Supreme Court direction that is well meant but, he argues, over-broad. It connects three high-yield themes: police reforms and FIR registration, human trafficking, and the autonomy of adults against honour crimes. For background, read it with our 23 May report on the Supreme Court’s missing-child directions.
GS Paper 2: Mechanisms, laws and institutions for the protection of vulnerable sections; the judiciary; police and criminal justice. GS Paper 1: Social issues: women, marriage and caste; social empowerment.
Background and Context
| Case or law | What it established |
|---|---|
| Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P. (Constitution Bench, 2013) | FIR registration is mandatory if information discloses a cognisable offence; a preliminary inquiry is allowed only in limited categories (matrimonial disputes, commercial offences, medical negligence, corruption, abnormal delay), and must be time-bound |
| Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2013) | Mandatory FIR for every missing child; a presumption of abduction or trafficking unless investigation shows otherwise; special juvenile police units and trained officers at police stations |
| G. Ganesh v. State of Tamil Nadu (22 May 2026, clarified 5 August 2026; the background to this column) | Pan-India directions on missing children (immediate FIR, anti-trafficking units, databases), arising from a child missing in Chennai since 2011; the August order, the author writes, extended the FIR mandate to every missing “person” |
| Section 173, BNSS, 2023 (in force since 2024) | Replaced Section 154 CrPC; allows Zero FIR and e-FIR; Section 173(3) permits a preliminary enquiry within 14 days, with the permission of an officer of Deputy Superintendent rank or above, for offences punishable with three to seven years |
Why adults are different. In Lata Singh v. State of U.P. (2006) and Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M. (2018), the Supreme Court held that an adult’s choice of partner is protected by Article 21. In Shakti Vahini v. Union of India (2018) it laid down preventive, remedial and punitive measures against honour crimes, including protection for couples who fear their families.
The Analysis
1. The presumption fits children, not adults. For a child, consent is legally irrelevant, so disappearance is itself a red flag and speed saves lives. An adult may leave home lawfully, and treating every such departure as a presumed crime reverses the burden against the person’s own choice.
2. The FIR sets off a chain. Once a kidnapping FIR is registered, the police are duty-bound to trace the person, often to produce them before a magistrate or hand them back to the family. For an inter-caste or inter-faith couple, that chain can end in violence.
3. A notice to the police does not stop the pursuit. Even when an adult leaves word of their willingness, the author notes, the police would still have to trace them to verify it. The adult’s statement should close the matter where there is no sign of coercion.
4. Procedure matters. The author points out that the question of missing adults was not before the Court, and that the States do not appear to have been heard. Broad directions from narrow facts are a recurring criticism of judicial policy-making.
5. The law already knows the middle path. Section 173(3) of the BNSS allows a 14-day preliminary enquiry for mid-level offences. The author asks for a similar “week or fortnight” to filter missing-adult reports, not for abandoning registration.
Data and Institutions Vault
Prelims-grade facts:
The law on FIRs:
- Section 173, BNSS, 2023 replaced Section 154, CrPC; in force since 2024 (1 July 2024).
- Zero FIR: information can be given at any police station irrespective of jurisdiction; e-FIR is recognised.
- Section 173(3): preliminary enquiry within 14 days for offences punishable with 3 to 7 years, with DSP-rank permission.
- Lalita Kumari (2013): registration mandatory; limited categories allow a preliminary inquiry.
Children and trafficking:
- Bachpan Bachao Andolan (2013): FIR mandatory for missing children; presumption of abduction or trafficking.
- Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTUs) operate at the district level.
- JJ Act, 2015 (Section 107): a Child Welfare Police Officer in every police station; a Special Juvenile Police Unit in every district.
Adults and choice:
- Lata Singh (2006) and Shafin Jahan (2018): choice of partner protected by Article 21.
- Shakti Vahini (2018): guidelines against honour crimes.
Prelims, the traps:
- Lalita Kumari did not ban preliminary inquiries; it confined them to specified categories.
- The BNSS preliminary enquiry is for offences punishable with 3 to 7 years, not for all offences.
⚠️ Watch the trap: “Mandatory FIR” does not mean “mandatory arrest”. Registration starts an investigation; arrest is governed by separate safeguards.
The Debate
For the author’s view. Criminal law should not presume a crime where an adult has exercised a constitutional freedom. A short enquiry would protect couples and save police time for genuine abductions.
Against it. Discretion at the registration stage is exactly what Lalita Kumari removed, because police stations used it to keep crimes off the books. Trafficking of adult women is real, and the first hours matter; a filter could let genuine cases slip.
The balanced verdict. Distinguish, do not dilute. Keep mandatory FIRs for children and whenever there is any sign of force, fraud or a minor involved. For adults, allow a short, recorded, time-bound enquiry in which the person’s own statement, taken directly, carries decisive weight, with protection under Shakti Vahini where needed.
How to Think About This
Ask who the law is protecting in each case. A presumption is a tool that shifts risk. For a child, it shifts risk away from the vulnerable person. For an adult who has left by choice, the same presumption can shift risk onto them. Good answers show that the same rule can protect or endanger depending on whom it is applied to.
Diagram-in-Words
Mandatory registration of FIRs protects the vulnerable but can also be turned against the autonomy of adults. Discuss with reference to missing-person cases and suggest safeguards. (250 words)
Registration of an FIR sets the criminal law in motion. In Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh (2013), a Constitution Bench held registration mandatory when information discloses a cognisable offence, allowing a preliminary inquiry only in limited categories.
Section 173 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 carries this forward.
For missing children, mandatory FIRs are justified. A child cannot consent, trafficking networks move fast, and Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2013) directed the police to presume abduction or trafficking unless investigation showed otherwise.
For adults the calculus changes. An adult has a constitutional right to choose where and with whom to live, recognised in Lata Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2006) and Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M. (2018).
Many adults reported missing have left voluntarily, often to marry against their families’ wishes. If every report must become an FIR presuming kidnapping, the police are obliged to trace and produce them, which can deliver couples to the very families that threaten them; Shakti Vahini v. Union of India (2018) required preventive, remedial and punitive measures against honour crimes precisely because of this danger.
The law already recognises calibrated inquiry: Section 173(3) of the BNSS permits a 14-day preliminary enquiry, with a senior officer’s permission, for offences punishable with three to seven years. The risk on the other side is police reluctance to register crimes, which mandatory registration was designed to curb.
The answer lies in distinguishing, not diluting. Mandatory FIRs should remain the rule for children and wherever there is any sign of coercion, while missing-adult reports could be subject to a short, time-bound enquiry that records the adult’s own wishes, backed by protection for couples at risk.
Interview Angle
"An adult woman leaves home to marry a man of another caste and her parents file a missing-person report. As the SHO, what do you do in the first 48 hours?"
Takeaway Box
- Direction: FIR for every missing “person”, presuming kidnapping or trafficking (G. Ganesh, 2026).
- Author’s objection: right for children, risky for adults who leave by choice.
- Legal anchors: Lalita Kumari (2013); Bachpan Bachao Andolan (2013); BNSS Section 173(3); Lata Singh, Shafin Jahan, Shakti Vahini.
- Proposal: a week or fortnight’s preliminary enquiry for missing adults.
- Risk to manage: police reluctance to register genuine crimes.
Sources: The Hindu, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (India Code), Supreme Court of India
R.K. Vij argues that the Supreme Court’s direction to register an FIR on every report of a missing person, with a presumption of kidnapping or trafficking, is sound for children but problematic for adults, because many adults leave home by choice, and police tracing them can expose consenting couples to family violence; a short preliminary enquiry should be allowed.
- In G. Ganesh v. State of Tamil Nadu, the Court issued directions in May 2026 on missing children and, on 5 August 2026, clarified that “person” covers every missing person, not only children.
- The directions echo Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2013), where the Court mandated FIRs for missing children and a presumption of abduction or trafficking unless investigation proves otherwise.
- A child’s consent has no legal relevance, so a presumption of a cognisable offence is justified; an adult who leaves voluntarily is in a different position.
- Couples who marry against parental wishes are usually first reported as missing; if every report becomes an FIR, the police must trace and often hand them over, and some couples have been killed after being found.
- The States were apparently not heard on missing adults, and the case before the Court concerned a child missing since 2011.
Any delay in registration can cost lives in trafficking and abduction cases, where the first hours matter most; a discretionary enquiry window has historically been used by police to avoid registering crimes, which is why Lalita Kumari made registration mandatory.
Keep mandatory FIRs for children; for adults, allow a short, time-bound preliminary enquiry, record the adult’s own statement where they can be contacted, and follow the Supreme Court’s guidelines on protecting couples from honour crimes.
Cite this page: The Pitfalls of Mandatory FIRs: Missing Adults, Consenting Couples and the Case for a Short Enquiry — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis