The Lift Line

“The question is no longer whether India can harvest the sun. It is whether India’s farmers can own a meaningful share of that harvest.”

Why This Editorial Matters for Your Exam

Ashok Gulati, Distinguished Professor, and Subhodeep Basu, Research Fellow, both at the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (ICRIER), combine three GS3 topics in one argument: farm incomes, power sector finances and the energy transition. The column’s data on scheme design and subsidies are directly usable in answers on agriculture, energy and discoms.

GS Paper 3: Infrastructure (energy); farm subsidies; issues of agricultural pricing and incomes; conservation of land and resources; government schemes.

Background and Context

India’s solar build-out, as the column describes it.

Segment Share of installed solar Driver
Utility-scale (ground-mounted parks) about 74 per cent Large developers on degraded or government land, including the Khavda renewable energy park in Kutch, Gujarat, planned for about 30 GW of solar and wind
Rooftop about 20 per cent PM Surya Ghar: Muft Bijli Yojana
Off-grid and hybrid about 6 per cent Solar pumps, mini-grids

Installed solar capacity was 2.82 GW just before 2014 and 168.04 GW by August 2026, according to the authors, making India the third-largest solar market after China and the United States.

The two schemes compared.

Feature PM Surya Ghar: Muft Bijli Yojana (2024) PM-KUSUM (2019)
Target group Households (rooftop) Farmers
Outlay or target Outlay Rs 75,021 crore; 1 crore households Three components (below)
Central support Rs 30,000 per kW for the first 2 kW and Rs 18,000 for the third; Rs 78,000 maximum Capital support for pumps (Components B and C); none for Component A plants
Other finance A World Bank loan of USD 820 million, the column says No equivalent window, the authors note

PM-KUSUM’s three components.

Component What it supports
A Decentralised grid-connected solar or other renewable plants of up to 2 MW on farmers’ land; power sold to discoms
B Standalone off-grid solar pumps
C Solarisation of existing grid-connected pumps, including feeder-level solarisation

The subsidy problem. Agriculture consumes about 2,60,000 GWh of electricity a year. The authors cite a CAG report putting the average cost of supply at about Rs 8.5 per kWh against realisation of about Rs 1 per kWh from farm consumers, with agriculture accounting for close to 85 per cent of a tariff subsidy bill of about Rs 2.35 lakh crore a year.

The Analysis

1. The boom has had a narrow base. Utility-scale parks were the fastest, cheapest way to add capacity, and rooftop subsidies spread it to households. The farmer, the biggest recipient of power subsidies, was left largely as a consumer.

2. Component A is the missing link. It already lets farmers host plants of up to 2 MW. Without capital support, few small farmers can raise the money, so the model tends to become land leasing to developers.

3. Agrivoltaics resolves the land conflict. Panels about 11 feet high, spaced for cultivation, let land produce food and power. The authors would ban ground-mounted solar on cultivable land and promote agri-PV instead.

4. The subsidy can be recycled. A feed-in tariff of about Rs 4.5 per kWh, roughly half the cost of rural supply, would make projects viable while costing discoms less than supplying the same power from afar.

5. A cooperative model. Drawing on Operation Flood, the authors propose solar cooperatives (“PM Surya Khet Kranti”) backed by catalytic finance, and even solar plants at gaushalas. They add that future projects should plan for storage and local grids as AI data centres push up demand.

Data and Institutions Vault

Prelims-grade facts:

Schemes:

  • PM-KUSUM (Pradhan Mantri Kisan Urja Suraksha evam Utthaan Mahabhiyan): 2019, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy.
  • PM-KUSUM components: A (plants up to 2 MW), B (standalone pumps), C (solarising grid-connected pumps).
  • PM Surya Ghar: Muft Bijli Yojana (2024): outlay Rs 75,021 crore, 1 crore households, up to 300 units free a month.
  • Rooftop subsidy: Rs 30,000/kW up to 2 kW, Rs 18,000 for the third kW, capped at Rs 78,000.

The column’s numbers:

  • Solar capacity: 2.82 GW (pre-2014) to 168.04 GW (August 2026).
  • ICRIER pilot: 600 kW under PM-KUSUM-A in Rajasthan; income potential from about Rs 40,000 to nearly Rs 4 lakh per acre.
  • Proposed feed-in tariff: about Rs 4.5 per kWh.

Prelims, the traps:

  • Khavda in Kutch is a hybrid renewable energy park (solar and wind), not a solar-only park.
  • Operation Flood (from 1970, NDDB) was financed in its first phase by the sale of donated dairy commodities; World Bank loans supported its later phases.

⚠️ Watch the trap: under PM-KUSUM, capital subsidy goes to pumps (Components B and C); Component A plants earn through power sales.

The Debate

For the authors’ view. Agri-PV turns a fiscal drain into an income source, spreads the energy transition to villages and keeps land in cultivation. Pilots show large income gains.

The complications. Elevated structures cost more than ground-mounted solar; yields of many crops drop under shade; distribution companies may not absorb or pay for decentralised power reliably; and without aggregation, small farmers may end up as lessors rather than owners.

The balanced verdict. Target concessional finance and aggregation (cooperatives, FPOs) at small farmers, match crops to partial shade, strengthen feeders and storage, and enforce payment discipline, so that the benefits reach cultivators and not only developers.

How to Think About This

Follow the subsidy rupee. Any energy-agriculture question gets sharper if you ask where the subsidy currently goes (below-cost farm power), who bears it (State budgets and discoms), and how a reform redirects it (paying farmers for power instead of subsidising their consumption).

Diagram-in-Words

Subsidised farm power cost about 8.5, paid about 1 Component A gap no capital subsidy Agrivoltaics on the farm PSL credit, feed-in tariff Farm income rises power plus crops Subsidy bill falls local power, lower cost
Paying farmers to produce power on land that still grows crops turns a consumption subsidy into an income stream and eases discom finances.
✍️ Mains Answer Framework
Question

India's solar expansion has been led by utility-scale parks and rooftop subsidies, while farmers have gained little. Discuss how agrivoltaics under PM-KUSUM can raise farm incomes, ease the power subsidy burden and protect food production. (250 words)

India’s solar capacity has grown dramatically in the past decade, led by large ground-mounted parks and, more recently, subsidised rooftop systems. Farmers, the largest users of subsidised electricity, have gained comparatively little, although the PM-KUSUM scheme of 2019 was designed to make them energy producers.

Agrivoltaics, which mounts solar panels high enough to allow cultivation beneath, lets the same land yield both food and power. It addresses three problems at once.
It raises and stabilises farm incomes by adding a steady power revenue to volatile crop earnings. It eases the burden of agricultural power subsidies, a major cause of distribution company losses, when the farm supplies power near the point of use at a tariff below the cost of supply.
And it avoids the conversion of cultivable land to ground-mounted solar. The obstacles are finance and design.
Component A of PM-KUSUM, which permits plants of up to 2 MW on farmers’ land, offers no capital subsidy, unlike rooftop schemes for households, and small farmers cannot raise the capital. Policy can respond with concessional credit under priority sector lending, a differentiated feed-in tariff, cooperatives or farmer producer organisations to aggregate small holdings, and crop choices suited to partial shade.
Grid capacity, storage and discom payment discipline must improve alongside.

Making solar a third crop for farmers would align three national goals: doubling farm incomes, fiscal relief for the power sector and the energy transition. The test is whether the benefits reach small farmers rather than only developers who lease their land.

Interview Angle

"If farmers can earn more from selling solar power than from growing grain, what happens to food security? How would you design the policy?"

Takeaway Box

  • Problem: the solar boom is utility-scale and rooftop-led; farmers largely left out.
  • Gap: PM-KUSUM Component A (up to 2 MW) has no capital subsidy.
  • Solution: agri-PV with priority-sector credit and a feed-in tariff near Rs 4.5/kWh.
  • Evidence: a 600 kW ICRIER pilot in Rajasthan showing a tenfold income potential.
  • Model: solar cooperatives on the lines of Operation Flood.

Sources: The Indian Express, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy, PM Surya Ghar portal

Key Arguments at a Glance

Ashok Gulati and Subhodeep Basu argue that India’s solar boom has bypassed farmers because PM-KUSUM’s Component A offers no capital subsidy, and that agri-photovoltaics, financed at priority-sector rates with a differentiated feed-in tariff, could raise farm incomes eight to ten times, cut the power subsidy bill and keep land in food production.

Supporting
  • Installed solar capacity rose from 2.82 GW before 2014 to 168.04 GW by August 2026, the authors write; about 74 per cent is utility-scale, 20 per cent rooftop and 6 per cent off-grid or hybrid.
  • PM Surya Ghar gives a household up to Rs 78,000 in central subsidy for a 3 kW rooftop system, and some States add more; PM-KUSUM Component A, which lets farmers set up plants of up to 2 MW, has no capital subsidy.
  • Ground-mounted solar on farmland competes with food; agri-PV panels raised about 11 feet allow cultivation underneath.
  • An ICRIER pilot of 600 kW in Rajasthan raised potential income from about Rs 40,000 per acre from wheat and bajra to nearly Rs 4 lakh through power sales and shade-tolerant horticulture.
  • Agriculture uses about 2.6 lakh GWh a year at a heavily subsidised tariff; a feed-in tariff of about Rs 4.5 per kWh, half the cost of supply, needs no extra spending, only smarter use of existing subsidies.
Counter

Agri-PV costs more per megawatt than ground-mounted solar, yields of many crops fall under shade, grid connectivity and discom finances limit how much decentralised power can be absorbed, and land-leasing models may benefit developers more than small farmers.

Way Forward

Offer capital support or concessional finance for Component A through priority sector lending, promote agri-PV rather than ground-mounted plants on cultivable land, set differentiated feed-in tariffs, and use solar cooperatives on the Operation Flood model to reach small farmers.

Cite this page: Solar as the Farmer's Third Crop: Agrivoltaics, PM-KUSUM and the Power Subsidy Trap — Ujiyari.com | Free UPSC & State PCS Editorial Analysis