GS Paper 1: History, Geography & Society
Q1. Seventy-five years ago India began its first general election under universal adult franchise. Examine the challenges the Election Commission faced in 1951-52 and how they were overcome. What lessons does that election hold for electoral democracy today?
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: Polling in India’s first general election began on 25 October 1951 in Chini and Pangi in Himachal Pradesh and ended on 21 February 1952 in Uttar Pradesh. A newly independent, largely unlettered country of over 17 crore electors chose its Parliament and State Assemblies in one exercise, a decision that was then widely seen as a gamble.
The Challenges
- Scale: 17,32,13,635 electors (excluding Jammu and Kashmir), about 45 per cent of them women.
- Literacy: most voters could not read a ballot paper bearing names.
- Logistics: 1,32,560 polling stations and 1,96,084 booths across mountains, deserts and forests.
- A blank legal slate: the Election Commission had existed only since 25 January 1950.
How They Were Overcome
- Constitutional foundation: Article 324, in force from 26 November 1949, placed superintendence of elections in an independent Commission; Sukumar Sen became the first Chief Election Commissioner on 21 March 1950.
- Legal architecture: the Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls, delimitation) and the Act of 1951 (conduct of elections).
- Design for the unlettered: a separate ballot box for each candidate, marked with a party symbol.
- Time as a resource: polling was spread over about 120 days, against 19 days in 1957.
- Result: turnout of 51.15 per cent (ECI report) for 489 elected Lok Sabha seats; the first Lok Sabha was constituted on 17 April 1952.
Lessons for Today
- Inclusion first: the franchise was given before literacy, not after it; the voting age was lowered from 21 to 18 by the 61st Amendment (1988).
- Trust rests on accurate rolls and a neutral umpire.
- Technology must serve the voter, as symbols once did.
Conclusion: The 1951-52 election turned the Constitution’s promise of political equality into practice. Its lesson is that the legitimacy of elections rests on the confidence of the least powerful voter.
Key concepts: universal adult franchise; Article 324; RPA 1950 and 1951; electoral integrity; political equality.
Q2. Cyclone Arnab of October 2026 showed both the gains and the gaps in India’s cyclone preparedness. Explain why the east coast is more prone to cyclones, and examine India’s institutional framework for cyclone risk management.
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: A deep depression over the Bay of Bengal intensified into Cyclonic Storm Arnab at 0530 IST on 26 October 2026. The very severe cyclonic storm crossed the Andhra Pradesh and Yanam coasts on the morning of 28 October. Andhra Pradesh put its loss at Rs 4,600 crore “as per the government’s preliminary assessment”, and seven people died in the State.
Why the East Coast Is More Vulnerable
- Warm, shallow Bay of Bengal: high sea surface temperatures feed storms, and post-monsoon months (October to December) are a peak season.
- Funnel-shaped bay and flat deltas (Godavari, Krishna, Mahanadi) amplify storm surge and flooding.
- Dense populations of fishers and farmers live on low coasts.
- Inland rainfall: Arnab’s rain hit Odisha’s Ganjam district, with 546 mm at Patrapur in the 24 hours ending 8.30 a.m. on 29 October (IMD) and 42,500 people marooned in Ganjam, as The Hindu reported.
The Institutional Framework
- Warning: IMD’s ladder of pre-cyclone watch, cyclone alert and cyclone warning; for Arnab, a Cyclone Warning marked “Red Message” for Andhra Pradesh and south Odisha.
- Command: the National Crisis Management Committee, chaired by the Cabinet Secretary, reviewed preparedness on 26 October with the directive of “zero loss of life”; the Disaster Management (Amendment) Act, 2025 gave the NCMC statutory status.
- Response: NDRF and SDRF battalions pre-positioned; boats recalled; Andhra Pradesh said it would shift 4,711 pregnant women to safer health facilities, and 30,043 fishing boats returned to harbour.
- Recovery: Central teams assess damage for relief.
Gaps
- Losses to crops, houses and power lines remain large even when lives are saved.
- Inland flooding gets less attention than landfall.
- Shelters, mangroves and resilient housing lag behind warnings.
Conclusion: India has largely moved from counting deaths to counting damage. The next step is to protect livelihoods and assets through resilient infrastructure and coastal ecosystems.
Key concepts: storm surge; IMD warning stages; NCMC; NDMA; NDRF; Sendai Framework; mangrove shields.
Q3. The first National Household Travel Survey shows that India’s cities move largely on two-wheelers while women travel far less for work than men. Discuss the implications of these findings for urban planning and gender equity.
[GS-1 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On 5 October 2026 the National Statistics Office (MoSPI) released the first National Household Travel Survey (NHTS), covering 4,92,023 households and 20,34,371 persons between July 2025 and June 2026. It gives India its first national picture of how people move.
Key Findings
- Two-wheeler dependence: 42.6 per cent of workers who commute to a fixed workplace go mainly by two-wheeler; 52.3 per cent in urban areas.
- Thin mass transit: metro, monorail, suburban rail and trams carry only 5.0 per cent of urban worker commutes, though 20.7 per cent in Maharashtra, 16.5 per cent in West Bengal and 14.4 per cent in Delhi.
- Students walk: 37.0 per cent of students walk to school or college.
- Gender gap: 61.9 per cent of male workers make daily work trips against 41.9 per cent of female workers; men spend Rs 835 a month on commuting, women Rs 533.
Implications for Urban Planning
- Private vehicles fill the gap left by sparse bus fleets and poor last-mile links, adding to congestion, emissions and road deaths.
- Metro investment pays off only with feeder buses, walkable streets and integrated ticketing.
- The National Urban Transport Policy, 2006 asked cities to plan for “people, not vehicles”; the survey shows how far that remains unmet.
Implications for Gender Equity
- Lower mobility narrows women’s job choices and contributes to low female labour force participation.
- Safety, lighting, frequent buses and affordable fares shape whether women travel at all.
- Lower spending may reflect shorter, local trips and fewer options, not only lower need.
Way Forward
- Expand bus fleets and feeder services; safe footpaths and cycle tracks near schools.
- Gender-disaggregated transport planning and Unified Metropolitan Transport Authorities.
Conclusion: The NHTS turns mobility from guesswork into evidence. Cities that plan for the walking student and the working woman will plan well for everyone.
Key concepts: NHTS; modal share; last-mile connectivity; NUTP 2006; gendered mobility; transit-oriented development.
GS Paper 2: Polity, Governance & International Relations
Q4. Several High Court rulings in October 2026 struck down State laws and orders that took reservation beyond 50 per cent. Examine the constitutional basis of the 50 per cent ceiling and the debate on whether it should remain.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In October 2026 three High Courts applied the 50 per cent ceiling. The Andhra Pradesh High Court (1 October) set aside orders fixing 34 per cent BC reservation in panchayats; the Madhya Pradesh High Court (9 October) struck down the raising of OBC reservation from 14 to 27 per cent; and the Karnataka High Court (12 October) struck down a 2022 Act that took total reservation from 50 to 56 per cent. The Supreme Court dismissed Andhra Pradesh’s appeal on 9 October.
Basis of the Ceiling
- Indra Sawhney (1992): reservation under Article 16(4) should ordinarily not exceed 50 per cent, save in “extraordinary” situations.
- Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil (2021): reaffirmed the ceiling and struck down Maharashtra’s Maratha quota.
- Local bodies: the “triple test” of K. Krishna Murthy (2010) and Vikas Kishanrao Gawali (2021) requires a dedicated commission, empirical data and a 50 per cent cap.
- The Constitution’s only textual reference to a “ceiling of fifty per cent” is Article 16(4B), on carried-forward vacancies, as the Madhya Pradesh High Court noted.
Arguments to Keep It
- Equality of opportunity (Article 16(1)) is the rule; reservation is a means, not an end.
- The ceiling forces data-based, not populist, decisions.
Arguments to Revisit It
- Population shares of backward classes may exceed half.
- The 10 per cent EWS quota, upheld in Janhit Abhiyan (2022), is outside the 50 per cent; Tamil Nadu’s 69 per cent sits in the Ninth Schedule, though I.R. Coelho (2007) keeps such laws open to basic-structure review.
A Related Limit
- On 15 October the Supreme Court held that a person who converts from a Hindu social order cannot claim Article 16(4) benefits merely on the basis of pre-conversion backwardness.
Conclusion: The ceiling balances merit and representation. Any change should rest on caste data, quantifiable backwardness and a constitutional amendment, not on ordinances.
Key concepts: Article 16(4); Indra Sawhney; triple test; EWS; Ninth Schedule; basic structure.
Q5. The Supreme Court in October 2026 recognised that children, irrespective of their age, enjoy the right to access and use the internet. Critically examine how the State can protect children online without denying them this right.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In an order of 15 October 2026 (made public on 17 October), a Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K.V. Chandran held that “the right to access and use the internet is a fundamental right of every individual under Article 21 read with Article 19(1)(a)”, and that children enjoy the same rights. It found blanket bans on children’s internet use disproportionate.
Why Access Matters
- Education, information, expression and later employment depend on the internet.
- Anuradha Bhasin (2020) protected speech and trade over the internet; this order speaks of access itself.
- Bans shut out the poor and rural child more than the protected urban one.
The Risks to Children
- Child sexual abuse material, grooming, cyberbullying, addictive design, fraud and data harvesting.
Protection Without Denial
- Targeted blocking: the Court asked for a National Hash and URL List Database of abuse material, with review by trained human analysts.
- Existing law: Section 67B of the IT Act punishes child sexual abuse material; the DPDP Act, 2023 (Section 9) requires verifiable parental consent for processing children’s data and bars tracking and targeted advertising.
- Awareness: the Court asked that helplines 1098 (children) and 1930 (cyber fraud) be displayed in classrooms.
- Platform duty: safety by design, age-appropriate defaults, quick takedown.
- Digital literacy for children, parents and teachers.
Limits and Concerns
- The Court did not order parental consent for children’s internet use; regulation remains for the legislature and executive.
- Age verification can itself threaten privacy.
- Further hearing is scheduled for 10 December 2026.
Conclusion: The order shifts the question from whether children should be online to how they can be safe there. Proportionate, targeted protection is the constitutional path.
Key concepts: Article 21; Article 19(1)(a); proportionality; DPDP Act Section 9; IT Act Section 67B; safety by design.
Q6. As the Union Public Service Commission completes a hundred years, examine its constitutional position and the challenges it faces in preserving merit, neutrality and public trust in recruitment.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: The first Public Service Commission was set up on 1 October 1926 under Section 96(C) of the Government of India Act, 1919, on the recommendation of the Lee Commission (1924), with Sir Ross Barker as its first Chairman. It became the Federal Public Service Commission under the 1935 Act and the Union Public Service Commission under the Constitution.
Constitutional Position
- Articles 315 to 323 provide for the UPSC and State Commissions.
- Security of tenure: a member may be removed only by the President under Article 317, on the grounds and procedure it lays down.
- Financial independence: expenses are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India (Article 322).
- Accountability: an annual report to the President, laid before Parliament (Article 323).
- Functions: conducting examinations and advising on recruitment, promotion and disciplinary matters (Article 320).
Challenges
- Integrity of examinations: impersonation and leaks elsewhere have shaken confidence in public exams; the UPSC used facial authentication at the Civil Services Preliminary Examination of 24 May 2026 for about 5.50 lakh candidates.
- Advisory, not binding: governments may depart from its advice, with reasons placed before Parliament.
- Lateral entry and contractual hiring raise questions about routes outside the Commission.
- Length of the cycle: a year-long process with heavy coaching dependence.
- Diversity: candidates from rural areas and Indian-language backgrounds.
Way Forward
- The UPSC’s centenary theme of “Trust, Transparency, Technology” points to secure, technology-aided processes.
- Shorter cycles, published reasoning on syllabus changes, and wider language access.
- Consistent standards for State Commissions, where most controversies arise.
Conclusion: A century on, the UPSC’s value lies less in the exams it runs than in the trust it carries. Guarding that trust is the core of its next century.
Key concepts: Articles 315 to 323; Lee Commission; security of tenure; merit system; examination integrity.
Q7. In October 2026 India gained relief from a threatened US tariff on buyers of Russian oil while its trade agreement with New Zealand came into force. Examine how India can protect its trade interests in an era of unilateral tariffs.
[GS-2 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: By an executive order of 16 October 2026, the US President used Section 115 of the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 to waive its duties, including a 100 per cent duty on goods from the largest five importers of Russian crude and gas making new purchases on or after 18 October. India, which imported about 1.9 million barrels a day of Russian crude in September (Kpler, cited by The Indian Express), was spared, for now, a duty that was waived before it applied. Days later, on 20 October, the India-New Zealand trade agreement entered into force.
The Challenge
- Secondary tariffs link trade access to India’s energy choices.
- Uncertainty: the waiver lasts until the US decides “further action is appropriate”.
- Erosion of WTO disciplines as major economies act unilaterally.
India’s Response So Far
- New Zealand agreement: New Zealand removes duties on all its tariff lines; India liberalises 70.03 per cent of lines covering 95 per cent of trade value, keeping dairy, sugar and edible oils out; quotas for apples, kiwifruit and Manuka honey; 5,000 temporary employment visas and 1,000 working holiday visas.
- Switzerland and EFTA: the TEPA marked its first year with a state visit on 5 October and a migration and mobility MoU.
- Strategic autonomy in energy buying, with diversified sourcing.
The Way Forward
- Diversify markets through FTAs that guard sensitive sectors such as dairy.
- Diversify energy suppliers to reduce exposure to any one sanction regime.
- Negotiate predictability with the US through a trade deal.
- Strengthen competitiveness through logistics, standards and the Production Linked Incentive schemes.
- Defend rules-based trade at the WTO alongside partners.
Conclusion: India cannot control others’ tariffs, but it can widen its options. A spread of agreements, suppliers and markets is the best insurance against coercion.
Key concepts: secondary tariffs; strategic autonomy; FTA; tariff rate quota; TEPA; WTO.
GS Paper 3: Economy, Environment, Science & Security
Q8. In October 2026 the RBI raised the repo rate for the first time since February 2023 and introduced a Foreign Exchange Risk Reserve. Should monetary policy respond to inflation driven by supply shocks? Critically examine.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: The 63rd meeting of the Monetary Policy Committee (5 to 7 October 2026) raised the repo rate unanimously by 25 basis points to 5.50 per cent, its first hike since February 2023, and changed its stance from neutral to calibrated tightening by four votes to two. It cited conflict in West Asia, higher crude prices, a deficient south-west monsoon and a strong El Nino. On 10 October the RBI required banks to keep 20 per cent of the rupee value of certain rupee hedging contracts as cash with it, as a Foreign Exchange Risk Reserve.
The Case Against Responding
- Rate hikes cannot add oil or food; supply shocks pass on their own.
- Higher rates slow growth and investment when the economy is already hit.
- Transmission is slow and partial.
The Case For Responding
- Second-round effects: fuel and food prices feed wages, transport costs and expectations. CPI inflation rose to 5.54 per cent in September, and WPI to 11.39 per cent.
- Credibility: the 4 per cent target (with a 2 to 6 per cent band), retained for 2026 to 2031, holds only if the RBI acts before expectations drift.
- Rupee stability: a weaker currency imports inflation; the FERR and derivative curbs aim to check speculative pressure.
- Measured response: a 25 basis point move signals intent without choking growth (GDP projected at 7.1 per cent for 2026-27).
Limits
- Fiscal and supply measures, such as fuel taxes, buffer stocks and import management, must share the load.
- Capital controls on hedging can raise costs for genuine importers.
Conclusion: A central bank should look through a one-off supply shock but not through a persistent one that threatens expectations. October’s calibrated hike is that middle path, and its success depends on fiscal and supply-side partners.
Key concepts: supply shock; second-round effects; inflation expectations; flexible inflation targeting; Section 45ZB; FERR.
Q9. The 57th GST Council meeting recommended withdrawing arrest powers and raising the threshold for prosecution. Discuss the case for decriminalising tax law and the safeguards needed against evasion.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: On 8 October 2026 the 57th GST Council, chaired by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, recommended a package of process reforms: omitting section 69 of the CGST Act, 2017 (arrest powers), raising the prosecution threshold from Rs 1 crore to Rs 5 crore, cutting the maximum general penalty under section 125 from Rs 25,000 to Rs 10,000, and system-based provisional refunds. These are recommendations; they take effect only through amendments, notifications and circulars.
The Case for Decriminalisation
- Trust-based compliance: most errors are procedural, not fraudulent; arrest threatens honest businesses, especially small ones.
- Ease of doing business: fear of coercive action deters formalisation.
- Proportionality: civil penalties and interest suit revenue disputes better than jail.
- Judicial burden: prosecution for small sums clogs courts.
- Consistency: it follows the Jan Vishwas approach of decriminalising minor offences.
The Risks
- Fake invoicing: organised rackets claim input tax credit on non-existent supplies.
- Weaker deterrence for large-scale fraud if enforcement is diluted.
Safeguards Needed
- Fraudulent input tax credit claims remain an offence under section 132; the higher threshold must not shelter organised fraud.
- Data analytics: e-invoicing, e-way bills and risk-based scrutiny to detect fake chains early.
- Strong civil recovery: attachment of property and cancellation of registration.
- Clear guidelines so that remaining powers are used uniformly across States.
Federal Angle
- The Council (Article 279A, added by the 101st Amendment, 2016) works by a three-fourths majority, with the Centre holding one-third of the votes, so reform needs both levels of government.
Conclusion: Decriminalisation is sound where it separates the honest mistake from the deliberate fraud. Technology-led enforcement must replace the threat of arrest, not merely remove it.
Key concepts: decriminalisation; trust-based governance; input tax credit; Article 279A; cooperative federalism.
Q10. October 2026 saw a tigress translocated to Buxa, cheetahs released in a new reserve and the first steps towards releasing captive-bred Great Indian Bustards. Examine the role and limits of active intervention in species conservation.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: Indian conservation is moving from protecting what survives to rebuilding what was lost. In October 2026 a tigress from Valmiki Tiger Reserve was released in Buxa Tiger Reserve (2 October); the process for the first release of two captive-bred Great Indian Bustards into an enclosure in the Desert National Park was initiated (3 October); and two cheetahs were released in Veerangana Durgavati Tiger Reserve (7 October).
Forms of Intervention
- Reintroduction: returning a species to range it has lost, as with tigers in Buxa, under IUCN guidelines (2013).
- Conservation breeding: 97 Great Indian Bustards are in captivity under Project GIB, against about 130 in the wild in Rajasthan (2024-25).
- Introduction of a lost species: Project Cheetah (from 17 September 2022) brought African cheetahs to India, where the cheetah went extinct in 1952; the population reached 60, of which 41 are Indian-born, after five cubs were born at Kuno on 5 October.
- Habitat protection: Sukhna Lake and Sauj Jheel took India’s Ramsar sites to 103 (announced 15 October).
Why Intervention Is Needed
- Wild populations are falling: WWF’s Living Planet Report (8 October) found a 73 per cent average decline in monitored wildlife populations from 1970 to 2022, and 85 per cent in freshwater.
- Small, isolated populations cannot recover on their own.
Limits
- Habitat first: Buxa’s prey base was rebuilt (over 800 chital, about 380 hectares of grassland) before tigers came; without this, releases fail.
- Threats persist: power lines kill bustards, and the Supreme Court (M.K. Ranjitsinh, 2024) had to balance them with solar energy.
- Cost and welfare: animal deaths, high spending and dependence on management.
- Community acceptance around reserves.
Conclusion: Intervention buys time; only secure habitat, with local support, makes recovery last.
Key concepts: reintroduction; ex situ conservation; prey base; Ramsar Convention; Living Planet Index; 30x30 target.
Q11. Delhi’s winter air crisis is now met with command centres, source-apportionment laboratories and graded restrictions. Examine whether this data-driven approach can succeed without airshed-level governance.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In October 2026, Stage I of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) was invoked across the NCR on 21 October. On 24 October the Integrated Atmospheric Chemistry and Aerosol Toxicity Analysis Laboratory (AATAL) opened at IITM’s Delhi Branch under Mission Mausam. On 30 October the Union Environment Minister visited the CAQM’s command centre, PAVAN, and announced that construction and demolition across the NCR would be halted from 5 to 20 November.
The Data-Driven Toolkit
- PAVAN-I3C: integrates data from 111 continuous ambient air quality monitoring stations, over 2,300 industries and over 3,200 construction sites, on the principle “Detect, Analyse, Act”.
- AATAL: identifies what the air contains, where it comes from and how toxic it is.
- Forecasting: IITM’s AIRWISE forecasts air quality at 400 metres resolution for 72 hours.
- GRAP: 48 actions in four stages, triggered by AQI bands.
- Statutory power: the CAQM Act, 2021 lets the Commission issue binding directions.
Strengths
- Targeted enforcement in place of blanket bans.
- Forecasts allow action before pollution peaks.
- Source data can direct money to the biggest sources, such as road and construction dust.
Why Airshed Governance Is Still Needed
- Pollution ignores borders: crop-residue burning, power plants and industry in neighbouring States shape Delhi’s air.
- City action plans under the National Clean Air Programme (2019) work city by city.
- Emergency curbs return every winter; they treat the peak, not the base load.
- Blanket construction halts hurt daily-wage workers.
Way Forward
- Plans for the whole Indo-Gangetic airshed, with shared targets for States.
- Funding tied to measured reductions.
- Year-round action on transport, dust and residue use.
Conclusion: Data tells us where pollution comes from; only airshed-wide cooperation can stop it at source.
Key concepts: airshed; source apportionment; GRAP; CAQM Act 2021; NCAP; Mission Mausam.
Q12. “Digital arrest” scams combine impersonation of officials with failures in banking safeguards. Examine the measures needed to protect citizens from such cyber fraud, in light of the Supreme Court’s directions of October 2026.
[GS-3 | 15 Marks | 250 Words]
Introduction: In a “digital arrest” scam, fraudsters pose as police, investigators or judges on video calls, keep victims under watch and make them transfer money. There is no legal provision for a digital arrest in India. On 29 October 2026, a three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court called upon the RBI to make financial institutions indemnify victims, for not less than the amount lost, where the fraud results from a bank’s failure of due diligence. It will also examine the RBI’s proposed KYC Amendment Directions, 2026 before they are notified.
Scale
- National Cybercrime Reporting Portal complaints of digital arrest: 1,23,672 in 2024 and 58,239 in 2025 (I4C data recorded in the Court’s earlier order of 4 August 2026).
Why the Scams Succeed
- Fear of authority and lack of legal awareness.
- Mule accounts: weak KYC lets fraudsters move money quickly.
- Banks rarely flag unusual transfers by elderly customers.
- Jurisdictional gaps when gangs work from abroad.
Measures Needed
- Prevention in banks: suspension of unusual transactions, automated reporting and physical verification, as the Court sought.
- Shared liability: indemnity gives banks a reason to invest in safeguards.
- Fast reporting: the 1930 helpline and the Citizen Financial Cyber Fraud Reporting and Management System to freeze money in the first hours.
- Investigation: e-Zero FIRs, State cybercrime coordination centres and the CBI for large cases.
- Law: cheating by personation under the BNS and the IT Act (sections 66C and 66D).
- Awareness: that no agency arrests anyone over a video call.
- International cooperation against scam compounds abroad.
Conclusion: Digital arrest exploits trust in both the state and the bank. Restoring it needs banks that verify, police who respond fast and citizens who know the law.
Key concepts: digital arrest; mule accounts; KYC; I4C; due diligence; indemnity; cyber hygiene.
GS Paper 4: Ethics, Integrity & Aptitude (Case Studies)
Q13. You are the Deputy Commissioner of Police of a central district of a large city. A group of citizens plans a peaceful sit-in outside the office of a constitutional body to protest its decisions. Prohibitory orders are in force near the office, and you are under pressure to prevent any gathering. The previous day, protesters were detained in large numbers, and a court has since directed that there be no detention except in accordance with law and that peaceful assembly be allowed outside the prohibited zone.
(a) Identify the ethical issues involved. (b) What course of action would you take?
[GS-4 | 20 Marks | 250 Words]
Context: In October 2026 the Supreme Court held a special Sunday sitting on the handling of protests in Delhi and gave interim directions: no detention except in accordance with the procedure established by law, and peaceful assembly to be permitted beyond the area where orders under Section 163 of the BNSS were in force. Article 19(1)(b) guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms, subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(3).
(a) Ethical Issues
- Rights against order: the citizens’ right to protest against public order and the functioning of a public office.
- Rule of law: obedience to the court’s directions over informal pressure.
- Neutrality: the police must not appear to shield an institution from criticism.
- Proportionality: restrictions must be the least needed to keep order.
- Accountability: the earlier mass detentions raise questions of conduct.
(b) Course of Action
- Follow the law: enforce the prohibitory order only within its area; facilitate the sit-in outside it.
- Dialogue: meet the organisers to agree a site, timing, numbers and conduct.
- Calibrated deployment: women officers, video recording, clear routes for the public.
- No arbitrary detention: any detention only for a specific offence, recorded with reasons, with prompt information to families.
- Restraint: use of force only as a last resort and in proportion.
- Report upward: inform seniors in writing that the course follows the court’s directions.
- Review: examine the previous day’s detentions and correct errors.
Ethical Anchor: Public order protects democracy; it is not a reason to silence it. A police officer serves the Constitution, not the comfort of any office.
Key concepts: Article 19(1)(b); proportionality; rule of law; political neutrality; due process; accountability.
Q14. You are the head of medical affairs at a pharmaceutical company. The sales team proposes sponsoring doctors’ family holidays abroad, labelled as “scientific conferences”, to boost the sales of a new drug. The marketing code that applies to the industry is voluntary, and competitors are said to follow similar practices. The managing director is keen on quick results.
(a) Identify the ethical issues involved. (b) What would you do, and why?
[GS-4 | 20 Marks | 250 Words]
Context: In October 2026 the Department of Pharmaceuticals constituted a three-member committee, chaired by Dr. M. Srinivas, Member, NITI Aayog, to examine the regulatory framework for pharmaceutical marketing practices and recommend measures to curb unethical practices. The Uniform Code for Pharmaceutical Marketing Practices (UCPMP), 2024 bars gifts and travel for healthcare professionals except for speakers at continuing medical education, but it is a code, not an Act of Parliament.
(a) Ethical Issues
- Conflict of interest: inducements can bias prescriptions away from the patient’s interest.
- Patient welfare and cost: the cost of freebies is usually built into drug prices, as the Supreme Court observed in Apex Laboratories (2022).
- Honesty: disguising holidays as conferences is deception.
- Compliance against competition: “everyone does it” is not a defence.
- Professional integrity: doctors’ own ethics regulations bar gifts from the industry.
(b) Course of Action
- Refuse the proposal and record the reasons in writing.
- Explain the risk to the managing director: reputational damage, penalties under the code, and scrutiny as the government reviews regulation.
- Offer legitimate alternatives: genuine scientific meetings with transparent agendas, published clinical evidence, medical representatives trained to share balanced information.
- Strengthen internal controls: audit marketing spend, declare all payments to professionals, and set up a whistle-blower channel.
- Engage the industry association on uniform standards so that ethical firms are not disadvantaged.
- If overruled, escalate to the board or compliance committee rather than take part.
Ethical Anchor: Medicine rests on the patient’s trust that a prescription is written for her benefit. A company that protects that trust protects its own future.
Key concepts: conflict of interest; fiduciary duty; self-regulation; corporate governance; whistle-blowing; UCPMP 2024.
Essay
Q15. “Institutions are built on trust, and trust is built slowly but lost quickly.”
[Essay | 125 Marks | 1000-1200 Words]
Suggested outline for an essay grounded in October 2026 developments:
Hook and Thesis: Open with October 1951: in the snow of Chini and Pangi, voters who could not read dropped ballots into boxes marked with symbols, trusting that the count would be honest. Seventy-five years later, in October 2026, a retired person on a video call trusts a stranger in a police uniform and loses a lifetime’s savings. Thesis: institutions live on public trust, which is earned through fairness, competence and accountability over decades, and can be destroyed by a single failure.
Conceptual Frame:
- Trust as the belief that an institution will act fairly even when one cannot watch it.
- Trust as social capital: it lowers the cost of governance and markets.
- Its sources: rules, neutrality, competence, transparency and the ability to correct mistakes.
Illustrations:
(a) Elections: the first general election of 1951-52 built faith in the ballot through an independent Election Commission, careful rolls and patient design.
(b) Recruitment: the UPSC at 100 rests its standing on merit and secrecy; its centenary theme of “Trust, Transparency, Technology” and facial authentication at examinations show how trust must be defended.
(c) Money: the RBI’s inflation target and its October rate hike are acts of credibility; a central bank that is not believed cannot anchor prices.
(d) Banking and cybercrime: digital arrest scams exploit trust in officials and banks; the Supreme Court’s call for indemnity aims to restore it.
(e) Taxation: the GST Council’s recommendation to withdraw arrest powers reflects a move from suspicion to trust-based compliance.
Historical Anchoring:
- The Constituent Assembly’s choice of universal franchise as an act of faith in the people.
- Institutions such as the Comptroller and Auditor General and the judiciary that earned trust through independence.
Counter-arguments:
- Blind trust invites abuse; scepticism keeps institutions honest.
- Trust in institutions can hide their failures from scrutiny.
Synthesis: The aim is not blind trust but warranted trust: confidence that rests on transparency, accountability and redress. Institutions earn it by explaining decisions, admitting errors and protecting the weakest user.
Conclusion: Return to the voter of 1951 and the victim of 2026. The first trusted because the system deserved it; the second was betrayed by those who imitated the system. Protecting public trust is the first duty of every institution, because once lost it costs generations to rebuild.