🗞️ Why in News The Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) under MoEFCC directed Tamil Nadu to redesign the proposed International Dugong Conservation Centre at Manora, Thanjavur district, ensuring CRZ compliance and protection of surrounding seagrass habitats — underscoring the tension between conservation infrastructure development and the very ecosystems it aims to protect.
The Dugong — Biology and Identity
The dugong (Dugong dugon) is the sole living member of the family Dugongidae — a large, slow-moving marine mammal that feeds exclusively on seagrass. It is commonly called the “sea cow” for its herbivorous grazing behaviour. Though superficially whale-like, the dugong is more closely related to the elephant (order Proboscidea) than to any whale — both dugongs and elephants are members of the clade Afrotheria.
Physical characteristics:
- Length: 2.4–3.3 metres (adults)
- Weight: 230–500 kg
- Lifespan: up to 70 years (one of the longest-lived marine mammals)
- Distinctive features: paddle-like flippers, whale-like fluked tail (not rounded like manatees), downward-facing snout for bottom grazing, sparse hair across the body
- Breathing: surfaces to breathe every 1–3 minutes; can dive for up to 6 minutes
Dugong vs Manatee comparison:
| Feature | Dugong | Manatee |
|---|---|---|
| Family | Dugongidae | Trichechidae |
| Range | Indo-Pacific (marine only) | Atlantic + Amazon (freshwater too) |
| Tail | Fluked (whale-like) | Paddle-shaped (flat, rounded) |
| Closest relative | Elephant | Elephant |
| IUCN Status | Vulnerable | Variable (3 species: 1 Vulnerable, 1 EN, 1 LC) |
Both are in the order Sirenia (named after mermaids of sailor legend) — the only fully aquatic herbivorous mammals.
Seagrass — The Foundation
Dugongs are obligate seagrass grazers — they eat little else. Their survival is entirely dependent on the health and extent of seagrass meadows. This makes them one of the most habitat-specific large mammals on Earth.
Seagrass is not algae — it is a true flowering plant (angiosperm) that has returned to the sea. It:
- Produces oxygen through photosynthesis
- Traps sediments, stabilising the seafloor
- Is a blue carbon sink: seagrass meadows sequester carbon at up to 35 times the rate of tropical forests per unit area
- Provides habitat and nursery grounds for fish, prawns, and crabs (economically critical for fisheries)
- Is critically sensitive to: water turbidity, dredging, coastal runoff (especially fertiliser nutrients causing algal blooms), boat propeller scarring, and climate-driven warming
India’s Seagrass
India’s coastal seagrass is predominantly found in:
- Gulf of Mannar (Tamil Nadu): 14 species of seagrass; largest in India
- Palk Bay (Tamil Nadu): extensive shallow seagrass beds
- Andaman & Nicobar Islands: relatively undisturbed seagrass
- Lakshadweep: coral reef-associated seagrass
The Gulf of Mannar Biosphere Reserve (1989) and Gulf of Mannar Marine National Park (1986) protect some of the most biodiverse shallow coastal waters in India — including India’s primary dugong habitat.
India’s Dugong Population and Conservation
Status in India
India holds one of the largest remaining dugong populations in the world outside of Australia (which has by far the largest global population, particularly in Torres Strait and the Great Barrier Reef region). India’s dugong population is estimated at 100–200 individuals — concentrated in:
- Gulf of Mannar: shallow seagrass beds between Tamil Nadu coast and Sri Lanka
- Palk Bay: adjacent shallow waters
- Andaman & Nicobar Islands: less studied; population unknown
The population is declining due to:
- Incidental entanglement in fishing nets (bycatch) — the primary threat
- Motorboat strikes — dugongs surface frequently and are slow-moving
- Habitat loss: seagrass degradation from pollution, sedimentation, and coastal development
- Poaching: historically (dugong meat, oil, and bone were used in traditional medicine)
Legal Protections
| Legal Instrument | Protection |
|---|---|
| Wildlife Protection Act, 1972 | Schedule I — highest protection; hunting = severe penalty |
| CITES | Appendix I — prohibition on international commercial trade |
| IUCN Red List | Vulnerable (declining) |
| CRZ Notification 2019 | CRZ regulations protect coastal habitat from development |
Dugong Conservation Reserve — Gulf of Mannar (2013)
In 2013, the Tamil Nadu government declared the Dugong Conservation Reserve in the Gulf of Mannar — the first such reserve designated specifically for dugongs in the world. The reserve covers approximately 500 km² of shallow coastal waters.
The reserve was established under the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972 (as amended in 2002, which added Conservation Reserve provisions). Conservation Reserves are:
- Designated by state governments (unlike National Parks and Wildlife Sanctuaries, which require central notification)
- Buffer zones outside existing protected areas
- Allow regulated human activity (unlike Core Areas of Tiger Reserves)
The Proposed International Dugong Conservation Centre
The Tamil Nadu government proposed an International Dugong Conservation Centre at Manora, Thanjavur district — intended to serve as a:
- Research centre for dugong ecology and health
- Captive breeding facility (controversial — dugongs are extremely difficult to maintain in captivity)
- Public education and awareness centre
- Coordination hub for international dugong conservation networks
The Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) under MoEFCC reviewed the proposal and raised concerns:
- The proposed site is in or near the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) — construction near the coast is restricted
- Building the conservation centre could itself damage the seagrass meadows that dugongs depend on
- Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) requirements need to be addressed
- The EAC directed Tamil Nadu to submit a revised design that minimises ecological impact
This creates an irony: a facility meant to protect dugongs risking damage to the seagrass ecosystem that dugongs need to survive.
Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ)
The CRZ Notification, 2019 (under the Environment Protection Act, 1986) regulates activities within the coastal zone — classified into four types:
| Zone | Description | Key Restrictions |
|---|---|---|
| CRZ-I | Ecologically sensitive areas (mangroves, coral reefs, seagrass beds) | No construction |
| CRZ-II | Urban areas abutting shoreline | Limited construction |
| CRZ-III | Rural coastal areas | Restricted development |
| CRZ-IV | Water area (tidal water) | No reclamation except approved |
Seagrass beds fall within CRZ-I — the most protected category. Any construction near seagrass would require EAC clearance and potentially an environmental impact assessment under the EIA Notification, 2006.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims:
- Dugong: IUCN Vulnerable; CITES Appendix I; WPA Schedule I; Dugongidae; order Sirenia
- Only India dugong range: Gulf of Mannar + Andaman & Nicobar Islands
- Dugong Conservation Reserve: Gulf of Mannar, Tamil Nadu, 2013; first in world; under WPA 1972 (Conservation Reserve provisions)
- Seagrass: blue carbon sink; Gulf of Mannar has 14 species; largest in India
- CRZ: CRZ Notification 2019; four zones; seagrass = CRZ-I (no construction)
- Gulf of Mannar Biosphere Reserve: 1989; Marine National Park: 1986
- EAC: Expert Appraisal Committee under MoEFCC; grants CRZ clearances
Mains GS-3: Marine biodiversity; seagrass ecosystems; blue carbon; CRZ governance; conservation reserves; dugong threats and protection
📌 Facts Corner — Knowledgepedia
Dugong — Biology:
- Scientific name: Dugong dugon; family Dugongidae; order Sirenia
- Closest relative: elephant (Afrotheria clade)
- Length: 2.4–3.3 m; weight: 230–500 kg; lifespan: up to 70 years
- Tail: fluked (whale-like) — distinguishes from manatee (paddle-shaped tail)
- Diet: obligate seagrass grazer
- Breathing: surfaces every 1–3 minutes; dive up to 6 min
Conservation Status:
- IUCN: Vulnerable (declining population trend)
- CITES: Appendix I (commercial trade prohibited)
- WPA 1972: Schedule I (highest domestic protection)
India’s Dugong:
- Estimated population: 100–200 individuals
- Habitat: Gulf of Mannar + Palk Bay (Tamil Nadu) + Andaman & Nicobar Islands
- Primary threat: incidental bycatch in fishing nets, boat strikes, seagrass loss
- Dugong Conservation Reserve: Gulf of Mannar, TN, declared 2013 — first in world
Seagrass — Key Facts:
- True flowering plant (angiosperm) — not algae
- Blue carbon sink: sequesters carbon ~35x faster per area than tropical forest
- India’s largest seagrass: Gulf of Mannar (14 species)
- Threats: turbidity, dredging, fertiliser runoff, boat scarring, warming
Gulf of Mannar Protected Areas:
- Gulf of Mannar Marine National Park: 1986
- Gulf of Mannar Biosphere Reserve: 1989
- Dugong Conservation Reserve: 2013 (~500 km2)
CRZ Notification 2019:
- CRZ-I: ecologically sensitive (seagrass, mangroves, coral) — no construction
- CRZ-II: urban coastal areas — limited construction
- CRZ-III: rural coastal areas — restricted
- CRZ-IV: tidal water areas — no reclamation
EAC (Expert Appraisal Committee):
- Under: MoEFCC
- Function: grants environmental/CRZ clearances for coastal projects
- EIA: Environmental Impact Assessment required for large coastal projects
Other Relevant Facts:
- Manatees: 3 species (West Indian — Vulnerable; West African — EN; Amazonian — LC)
- Australia has world’s largest dugong population (Torres Strait, Great Barrier Reef)
- Conservation Reserve (WPA 2002 amendment): declared by state government; allows regulated activity
- Wildlife Sanctuary: declared by state; National Park: central/state; more restrictive
Sources: MoEFCC, Wildlife Institute of India, The Hindu